Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation

Culture Critic: The Winner's Reviews

Culture Critic.jpg

Back in April, we invited you to submit reviews of your favourite books by female authors. And after recieving thousands of entries, we crowned Rebecca Cosgriff, an NHS auditor from London, our winner. She wowed us with her thoughts on Emma Donoghue's Room - and was invited to write Stylist's Quiet Night In reviews page. Read her recommendations from the world of books and music below...

Picture credit: Rex Features

Eleven by Mark Watson

You may recognise Mark Watson’s name from TV panel shows such as Never Mind The Buzzcocks, Have I Got News For You and Mock The Week, from his pear cider ads or from his stand-up routine which he performs in a Welsh accent despite being from Bristol. But this, the comedian’s third novel, cements his reputation as a witty, sharply observant writer. Protagonist Xavier Ireland is a late night radio DJ with a Scrabble fetish and a chequered past.

A snowy day in the capital sees Xavier succumb to cowardice when he witnesses a brutal gang assault on a youth. The consequences of Xavier’s inaction reach out across the city as invisibly yet determinedly as radio waves, touching the lives of a number of disparate characters. There’s Julius Brown, a teenage mathematics enthusiast struggling with obesity, an effervescent Geordie cleaner, an estate agent with halitosis, and Murray, Xavier’s inept, stuttering sidekick.

As consequences build momentum, Watson settles into a narrative that is at once droll and devastating, littered with insightful analogies and poignant vignettes of city life. The modern urban dilemma of action versus inaction is deftly woven into an engaging plot, populated with relatable characters. Watson moves from one character to the next and back and forth in time, betraying tantalising details of Xavier’s haunted past, the current predicament of the 11 central characters, and the future of society at large; remaining hilarious throughout.

Eleven is out in paperback 9 June (£7.99, Simon & Schuster)

Medium Raw by Anthony Bourdain

Following his controversial Kitchen Confidential, Medium Raw mixes choice episodes from chef Bourdain’s past with analysis of the present food world: pessimistic advice for wannabe chefs alongside accounts of boozing with the Gadaffis on a Caribbean yacht. Hysterical musings by an x-rated Eeyore.

Out now in paperback (£8.99, Bloomsbury)

Mad by Moonlight by Thomas Tantrum

This second album from the UK indie four-piece blends Kate Bush-style vocals with raucous Ting Tingsesque music. Catchy and often comedic songs fill an album in which all the tracks are potential singles. Sleep stands out with its crisp lyrics and the inevitable toe tapping that accompanies it. Meanwhile, Hot Hot Summer conjures up being in the crowd of a sun-drenched festival.

Out 13 June, £13.99

Mr Fox by Helen Oyeyemi

Mr Fox is cheating on his wife with his imaginary friend. Mr Fox is also a serial killer; his heroines never make it out of a story alive. Oyeyemi has a sharp wit and isn’t afraid to use it. She punctuates the narrative with her protagonist’s own gruesome fairy tales; blurring the line between what you suppose is fact and hope to be fiction.

Out now (£12.99, Picador)

Want to be Stylist's next literary critic? Submit a 100 word book review for the chance to be published on stylist.co.uk.



Steps to becoming a world famous author


How to think creatively


Travel Photographer of the Year



The winner of the 2016 Man Booker Prize has been revealed

This author broke records to scoop the hottest literary prize of the year

by Francesca Brown
26 Oct 2016

Disney’s latest film project is big news for bookworms everywhere

What the Dickens?

by Kayleigh Dray
26 Oct 2016

Roald Dahl and Bake Off collide to make 5 amazing recipes

Forget Bake Off – it’s time for Quentin Blake-Off

by Kayleigh Dray
25 Oct 2016

Meet Jessika M., the queen of serial killer collectors

What makes a woman collect gruesome true crime memorabilia, from knives to letters and locks of hair?

by Moya Crockett
25 Oct 2016

Harry Potter fans, there's a real-life Hogwarts - and you can attend

Excuse us, we’re just heading to Diagon Alley for school supplies…

by Kayleigh Dray
24 Oct 2016

Harry Potter fans, there's a Roald Dahl collaboration in the works

Are you ready for a magical Willy Wonka prequel?

by Kayleigh Dray
20 Oct 2016

Sarah Jessica Parker is launching a new line of fiction books

She’s channelling her inner Carrie Bradshaw…

by Kayleigh Dray
20 Oct 2016

New Ladybird books for grown-ups are all our work woes

Old pics, new problems

by Anna Pollitt
18 Oct 2016

These are the UK’s favourite pearls of Winnie-the-Pooh wisdom

He’s far more than a bear of very little brain, you know.

by Moya Crockett
14 Oct 2016

Bridget Jones's author on life, love and the importance of friendship

“No one can have it all”

by Sarah Biddlecombe
12 Oct 2016