Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation

Emily Browning slams Twilight series as “emotionally abusive”


When Twilight author Stephenie Meyer first envisioned her YA vamp romance series becoming a film saga, she had only one person in mind for the lead character: Emily Browning.

However, the Australian actor, who broke out in The Uninvited and has more recently appeared alongside Tom Hardy in Legend, wasn’t interested, declining a chance to even audition for the part of Bella.


The role of Bella eventually went to Kristen Stewart

And now in an interview with The Telegraph, the 28-year-old has revealed exactly why the books didn’t “appeal” to her, calling them “emotionally abusive”.

“That was one of those internet things,” she told the newspaper. “I guess in one interview the author of the book mentioned my name in relation to that character, and people on the internet grabbed that and sort of ran with it.

“And yes, I was asked to – I wasn’t offered the part, which is what a lot of people have reported – but I was asked to audition for it. And it just wasn’t for me. I’d never heard of it at that point, but then I read the book and I just… No.”

Emily Browning

Browning can currently be seen in comic book adaptation American Gods

Drawn upon exactly what it was that she didn’t like in the books, Browning criticised the brooding male lead Edward Cullen: “I don’t want to say anything bad about it, but in my mind, the boy character – what’s his name?” [Edward] “The boy vampire seemed to be kind of emotionally abusive. That relationship just didn’t appeal to me, really.”

She did, however, have kinder words for Kristen Stewart, who of course eventually took the part of Bella: “I think she’s amazing, and I think she’s been so unfairly pigeonholed in people’s minds because of those films.”

Read more: 50 books that were banned

Browning, who admits she still hasn’t seen any of the Twilight films, had previously told The Huffington Post that if she had taken the role, the sheer amount of Twihards may have caused her to stop acting altogether: “I think I would have quit. I don’t think I would have been able to handle it.”

“Can you imagine having people taking your picture all day? It would be be awful,” she said. “Just like the last two days, [doing press and] having people waiting outside the hotel and stuff for us, it just makes me panic. I can’t imagine that being your everyday life.”

As for her thoughts on the potentially toxic nature of the stories, Browning isn’t the first to question the “emotionally abusive” elements between Edward and Bella, with one website even going so far as to see how their behaviour fared against the National Domestic Violence Hotline’s list of red flags. Worryingly, it passed the test.

Then again, perhaps we should have known the series wasn’t all it was cracked up to be when Robert Pattinson came out with this golden musing: 

"I could never legitimise why a 108-year-old guy would still want to be in high school.”


Images: Rex



Kristen Stewart on coming out during Donald Trump’s rise to power


“I won’t lose myself to my partner’s depression”


Selena Gomez teases return of 13 Reasons Why with series two trailer


The Peter Rabbit trailer has genuinely horrified Beatrix Potter fans

“They’ve… they’ve turned Peter into a frat boy!”

by Kayleigh Dray
22 Sep 2017

Practical Magic is FINALLY getting the prequel of your dreams

Flip the switch and let the cauldron bubble…

by Kayleigh Dray
14 Sep 2017

The Moomins are coming back to TV and the cast is incredible

Ready your Little My topknots

by Amy Swales
12 Sep 2017

Your £10 note is worth a LOT of money if it features this tiny detail

Oh Jane Austen, you’re spoiling us…

by Kayleigh Dray
12 Sep 2017

The Fifty Shades Freed trailer has arrived – and it’s pretty dark

Mrs Grey will see you now

by Amy Swales
11 Sep 2017

10 brilliant books to curl up with this September

From gripping crime fiction to beautiful poetry

by Sarah Shaffi
01 Sep 2017

Puberty guide causes fury with “problematic” explanation of breasts

The book said girls have breasts to make them look “grown-up and attractive”

by Sarah Biddlecombe
30 Aug 2017

The 5 biggest plot holes in Harry Potter, as exposed by fans

Accio problematic plot points!

by Susan Devaney
30 Aug 2017

50 unmissable books to kickstart your autumn reading

Your first look at the essential titles for autumn 2017

by Francesca Brown
25 Aug 2017

The 10 must-read books for anyone with siblings

There's often nothing more page-turning than the secrets between siblings

by Stylist
23 Aug 2017