Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation
Top

"My novel wasn’t the problem, it was me, Catherine." Author receives eight times more offers with male pseudonym

ThinkstockPhotos-467467196.jpg

We were always taught to never judge a book by its cover. But perhaps the greatest hurdle in literature is not judging a book by the author's name.

A female writer's pseudonym experiment is fast gaining attention in the publishing industry after she received almost nine times more manuscript requests when sending her query under a male name.

When American author Catherine Nichols found herself suffering from writer's fatigue - “I wasn’t feeling like a writer, and I hadn’t written in weeks,” she writes on Jezebel - and feeling crestfallen about studies on gender biases that favour men's names over women's, she decided to test the waters herself. 

She created an email address under the male name George Leyer and sent her cover letter and the opening pages of her novel from the new account to six publishing agents whom she planned to contact that day. Within 24 hours she had five responses, three of which were manuscript requests and two which were “warm rejections praising his exciting project”. 

“For contrast, under my own name, the same letter and pages sent 50 times had netted me a total of two manuscript requests,” she writes. “The responses gave me a little frisson of delight at being called “Mr.” and then I got mad...The judgments about my work that had seemed as solid as the walls of my house had turned out to be meaningless. My novel wasn’t the problem, it was me—Catherine.”

Woman writing

To make a direct comparison, she then sent out a total of 50 queries under George's name. Can you guess how many manuscript requests she received? Seventeen. “He is eight and a half times better than me at writing the same book,” says Nichols. 

She explains that publishers only accept submissions through agents, which makes them essential gatekeepers for anyone hoping to sell a book. Most of the agents Nichols contacted from her and George's account were different, but they did overlap on some occasions: “One who sent me a form rejection as Catherine not only wanted to read George’s book, but instead of rejecting it asked if he could send it along to a more senior agent.”

“Even George’s rejections were polite and warm on a level that would have meant everything to me, except that they weren’t to the real me. George’s work was 'clever,' it’s 'well-constructed' and 'exciting.' No one mentioned his sentences being lyrical or whether his main characters were feisty. A few of people sent deeply generous and thoughtful critiques, which made me both grateful and queasy for my dishonesty.”

 

Reading book

If we had to stack the number of books in history where female authors, from Louisa May Alcott to the Brontë sisters, adopted male names to combat sexism and prejudice at the time, they'd be collapsing over us, which is what makes Nichol's findings even more dispiriting. Has really nothing changed in the last two hundred years?

In 1837, when a 20-year-old Charlotte Brontë sent a few of her poems to England’s poet laureate Robert Southey, he responded, “Literature cannot be the business of a woman's life, and it ought not to be.”

Fast forward to 1997, when J.K. Rowling was told to use her initials instead of her name Joanne to attract more boy readers. In 2013, the author decided to pen her first crime fiction novel The Cuckoo's Calling under the male pseudonym Robert Galbraith instead of her own “to work without hype or expectation and to receive totally unvarnished feedback,” she said at the time.

A 2011 study found that the works by the four major publishers of literary fiction - Knopf, Crown, Little, Brown and Farrar, Strauss and Giroux - were overwhelmingly male, apart from Crown, publishers of Gillian Flynn's Gone Girl which had an even divide between the sexes.

“Unconscious bias is difficult to overcome,” writes Nichols, “But I feel furious at having spent so much time in that ridiculous little cage, where so many people with the wrong kind of name are burning out their energy and intelligence.”

Read Catherine Nichol's full piece at Jezebel.

 

Words: Sejal Kapadia, Images: Thinkstock

Related

books.jpg

The Man Booker Dozen: how many have you read?

MaryPortas_ShopGirl.jpg

The top 10 summer books, as recommended by the experts at Penguin

247_tablet_lisa_lead_v2.jpg

The 25 books every woman should read

zadie smith.jpg

Female authors who nailed their biggest bestseller under the age of 30

Exterior-1000-web.jpg

Enid Blyton’s old thatched cottage is up for sale

rexfeatures_594720a.jpg

The new app that literally puts women on the map

Comments

More

Jane Austen “never slept with a man” but may have had lesbian sex

The author was bawdier than people realise, historian says

by Anna Brech
29 May 2017

Bookstagrammers: the Insta tribe keeping it real on social media

They're not in it for money or exposure

by Anna Brech
26 May 2017

Blake Lively is set to star in her own version of Big Little Lies

Get ready for The Husband's Secret, everybody...

by Kayleigh Dray
26 May 2017

Watch: Anna Kendrick reveals her favourite female writers

"They have written these beautiful, funny, wonderful books.”

by Sarah Biddlecombe
25 May 2017

Why you should keep a list of every book you’ve ever read

An act of honesty in a 'fake' digital age

by Anna Brech
25 May 2017

UK publisher launches new imprint to address diversity in books

Fewer than 100 books written by non-white British authors were published last year

by Sarah Biddlecombe
16 May 2017

Emily Browning slams Twilight series as “emotionally abusive”

Aussie actor was Stephenie Meyer’s first pick to play Bella

by Joe Ellison
16 May 2017

Here’s how you can (legally) watch The Handmaid’s Tale in the UK

We finally have the answer

by Kayleigh Dray
16 May 2017

These are the books you need to read, according to female TED speakers

12 inspirational tomes to add to your reading list

by Sarah Biddlecombe
15 May 2017

Two brilliant word-of-mouth books to pop on your summer reading list

Load up your Kindle, pronto

by Anna Brech
10 May 2017