Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation
Top

Time to go back to paperback? Readers 'absorb less' on Kindles, study finds

hero.jpg
herokindle.jpg

Luddites may be vindicated by a new study that claims Kindle users don't absorb as much information as readers who stick to paperback books.

Europe-wide research into the impact of digitalisation on reading found that people who took in a short story on a Kindle had "significantly worse" recall of the plot than the ones who read it in paperback form, The Guardian reported.

"The Kindle readers performed significantly worse on the plot reconstruction measure, ie, when they were asked to place 14 events in the correct order," explained lead researcher Anne Mangen of Norway's Stavanger University.

The researchers suggest that the progress through pages of a paperback book provides a "sensory offload" that supports the reading process.

"Haptic and tactile feedback of a Kindle does not provide the same support for mental reconstruction of a story as a print pocket book does," Mangen said.

"When you read on paper you can sense with your fingers a pile of pages on the left growing, and shrinking on the right ... Perhaps this somehow aids the reader, providing more fixity and solidity to the reader's sense of unfolding and progress of the text, and hence the story," said Mangen.

Despite this, factors including empathy with characters, immersion in the story, and understanding of the narrative were relatively similar across e-readers and paperback readers.

The study also included only two experienced e-reader users, but Mangen - who wants to recreate the research using a greater proportion of Kindle converts - warned against assuming that the "digital natives" of today would perform better.

A paper last year found that Norwegian students who were given texts to read in print scored "significantly better" on a reading comprehension test than students who read same text in PDF form on a computer screen.

Mangen chairs a European research network into the wide-ranging implications of digitisation. The network says that "screen devices might negatively impact cognitive and emotional aspects of reading".

"It might make a difference if a novel is a page-turner or light read, when you don't necessarily have to pay attention to every word, compared to a 500-page, more complex literary novel, something like Ulysses, which is challenging reading that really requires sustained focus," Mangen said.

Related

darkfairytales.jpg

The eight darkest fairy tales

rexfeatures-3773601ai.jpg

Are fairy tales bad for children? Richard Dawkins claims they could be

rexfeatures-1826686a.jpg

You can learn a language while you sleep, says new study

true-romance.jpg

Unusual wedding poetry and readings: beautiful, moving and unique verses for your big day

one-day-hero.jpg

The 20 greatest books that are guaranteed to make you cry

hero.jpg

This summer's 10 bestselling Kindle books for under £5

Comments

More

The best new books to read in October 2016

From murder mysteries, to magical dream-quests by Sarah Shaffi

27 Sep 2016

The 10 best book-to-film adaptations have been revealed

Can the film ever be better than the book? by Kayleigh Dray

27 Sep 2016

The girl power cast for the Peter Rabbit movie is beyond incredible

The cast of Star Wars and Bridesmaids are teaming up for the Beatrix Potter adaptation by Kayleigh Dray

27 Sep 2016

Judge orders sex offender to buy feminist literature for victim

Titles include The Diary of Anne Frank and works by Virginia Woolf by Harriet Hall

26 Sep 2016

Why India’s latest comic book heroine is a rape survivor

In Priya's Mirror, the resilient heroine teams up with acid attack survivors to defeat gender-based violence. by Moya Crockett

26 Sep 2016

Girl on the Train author on the moment that sparked her smash hit book

And it was all down to the commute... by Sarah Biddlecombe

22 Sep 2016

The cast for The Handmaid’s Tale is beyond incredible

Yet another talented star has been added to the Margaret Atwood adaptation... by Kayleigh Dray

22 Sep 2016

This bestselling author is offering her cottage as a free writing spot

"Are you a writer, and wish you had some peace in which to write?" by Sarah Biddlecombe

20 Sep 2016

You can now buy one of the most famous houses in children’s literature

Magical news for muggles everywhere by Kayleigh Dray

19 Sep 2016

Pooh’s forgotten friend finally makes it to the Hundred Acre Wood

Are you ready for a brand-new Winnie-the-Pooh book? by Kayleigh Dray

19 Sep 2016