Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation

Ex-Vogue editor Alexandra Shulman had fashion “mansplained” to her and was not impressed


Until June this year, Alexandra Shulman was the editor-in-chief of British Vogue, a position she had held for 25 years. She announced that she was stepping down in January, and has since started a new role as a columnist at fashion industry bible Business of Fashion. But despite being one of the most high-profile and respected figures in British fashion, she says that she is still not immune to having her area of expertise mansplained to her.

Shulman recently appeared on the Today programme on BBC Radio 4 to discuss 60 years of change in the fashion industry with presenter John Humphrys. But while the interview began well, she says it quickly descended into “a denigration of the fashion industry and magazines”.

Writing for Mail Online, Shulman says that she had “all sorts of interesting things to say” about how fashion history had empowered women over the past six decades, such as “the emergence of nylon, acrylic and polyester, and how they helped to release women from the drudgery of the kitchen sink and ironing board”.

However, she says that Humphrys only wanted to discuss two things: the negative side of the fashion industry, and how Shulman had been complicit in promoting an unhealthy body image.

Read more: If you only buy 5 fashion pieces this autumn, make it these

“Suddenly I was confronted by a grey-haired guy in chinos hectoring me on the business I had worked in for a quarter of a century and which he neither knew, nor cared, much about,” the ex-editor writes.


John Humphrys and Alexandra Shulman. The former British Vogue editor-in-chief says she is tired of having to defend the fashion industry.

The Radio 4 presenter levelled various “ludicrous” accusations at Shulman regarding the “cruelty” of fashion, she says, including the suggestion that “women were forced to wear painfully high heels. As if we were promoting ancient Chinese foot-binding!”

Humphrys also argued that while “hourglass” figures were once in fashion, women now “have to be skinny as a rake” to succeed in fashion – and challenged Shulman for not including “reasonably cosy, comfortably shaped women” on the cover of Vogue.

Read more: JK Rowling spots mansplainer in the wild – and deals with him perfectly

Shulman has previously acknowledged the responsibility of designers and fashion editors to represent a diverse range of body types, although she has always maintained that thin models do not “give” girls eating disorders. In her conversation with Humphrys, she pointed out that she had featured women such as Rihanna, Adele and Ashley Graham in Vogue, “among others who are hardly rake-like”.

However, she says that she is tired of having “the same old limited, repetitious and banal conversation” about fashion with people who aren’t really interested in listening to her.


Shulman with Victoria Beckham and US Vogue editor Anna Wintour in September 2016.

“It is frustrating that fashion, a business that contributes a staggering £28 billion to this country’s GDP, which employs just short of a million people, which is a part of everybody’s daily life and which combines creativity and commerce in a uniquely fascinating way, is so often portrayed as a negative,” she writes.

“Fashion is not some weird and evil conspiracy that lures the unsuspecting into spending their hard-earned cash on things they don’t need. Nor is it some malign social force which encourages eating disorders, slave labour and narcissism.”

Shulman concludes: “Fashion is fun. It makes us feel good and adds to the whole richness and beauty of the world we live in. And I for one say hurrah for that.”

Images: Rex Features



These new ASOS jeans are guaranteed to make you feel very, very old


The best response to a man who tried to mansplain mansplaining


This deleted scene from The Devil Wears Prada changes everything


Elisabeth Moss hid secret “f**k you” to the patriarchy in Emmys outfit

We expected nothing less from The Handmaid’s Tale star

by Kayleigh Dray
19 Sep 2017

Behind the scenes at London Fashion Week

Candid backstage and party snaps from the capital of style

19 Sep 2017

Stars on the front row at London Fashion Week

The people, the parties, the on-point looks

by Anna Brech
19 Sep 2017

Join Stylist's fashion crew backstage at London Fashion Week

Immerse yourself in all the behind-the-scene action

18 Sep 2017

Daily outfit inspiration with our look at the best dressed A-listers

Casual dressing ideas from stylish celebrities

18 Sep 2017

What the Stylist team are wearing at Fashion Week

Check in here for style inspiration

18 Sep 2017

Amazon trials one-hour Prime Now deliveries with LFW show

Nicopanda capsule collection can be shopped straight from the catwalk

by Anna Brech
18 Sep 2017

Street style highlights from London Fashion Week

From hard-edged metallics to garish cartoon prints and flamboyant throwback trends

by Anna Brech
18 Sep 2017

From pink to pistachio, our favourite gelato moments from Fashion Week

Get the ice-cream trend licked

by Anna Brech
16 Sep 2017

Stylist celebrates the launch of its AW17 Fashion Issue

15 Sep 2017