Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation
Top

Rejection letters sent to famous people

hero3.jpg
hero2.jpg

"I love my rejection slips," wrote Sylvia Plath. "They show me I try.” It's not always easy to adopt Plath's words of wisdom when a crisp white rejection letter lands on your doormat (or, more likely, inbox).

But we can take consolation in the fact that some of the most successful stars have received rejection letters of their own at some point in their careers, before going on to find success.

From Madonna to Tim Burton, here are ten rejection letters sent to some of the biggest talents.


Andy Warhol

In 1956, Andy Warhol tried to give his work away for free and he couldn't. The artist received a letter from the Museum of Modern Art (MoMA) declining a drawing "which you so generously offered as a gift to the Museum". Today, MoMA owns 168 of Warhol’s pieces.


Madonna

This letter was written by the president of Millennium Records president Jimmy Lenner, to Madonna's team who felt the singer was not "ready yet". He continued, "I will pass for now, but I will wait for more". The date of the letter is unknown, but the star signed with Sire Records in 1982, a year before she released her first self-titled album, which has sold more than 10 million copies worldwide.

(Image credit: perezhilton.com)


Tim Burton

While still in secondary school, Burton sent a copy of his children’s book, The Giant Zlig, to Walt Disney Productions to be considered for publication. Editor at Walt Disney Productions was impressed with Burton's work, saying he demonstrated "a grasp of the English language better than I would expect from today's high school students". He was ultimately rejected for being “too derivative of the Seuss works to be marketable”. Of course, there's a happy ending. A few years later, the company took Burton on as an animator’s apprentice.


Sylvia Plath

The writer collected scores of rejection letters, even after the considerable success of her 1960’s The Colossus and Other Poems. In 1960, poetry editor of The New Yorker magazine, Howard Moss, wrote to Plath, politely dismissing her poem Amnesiac. He recommended she cut the entire first section of the poem and resubmit "the second section alone under that title."

(Image credit: Open Culture)


George Orwell

Even great writers like George Orwell suffered setbacks, such as when his novel Animal Farm was rejected as a “stupid and pointless fable” by Knopf Publishers in 1945. Several publishers refused the work, particularly because it was an attack on Britain’s wartime ally, the Soviet Union. When English published Frederic Warburg printed the book, 4,500 first edition copies sold within a few days. By 1973, the book had sold approximately nine million copies.

(Image credit: Instagram)


Alice Munro

Short-stories author, Alice Munro, won a Nobel Prize in Literature and is praised for having revolutionised the architecture of short stories. Her first collection of stories, Dance of the Happy Shades (1968) and won the Governor General’s Award, Canada’s highest literary prize. But the collection was first rejected by Knopf, where editor Judith Jones wrote: "As a collection I suppose there is nothing particularly new and exciting here".

(Image credit: Univeristy of Texas at Austin)


U2

In 1979, Bono, The Edge, Larry Mullen, Jr., and Adam Clayton released their first single in Dublin. But London-based RSO Records dismissed the band’s submission in May of the same year. They were sent a generic rejection letter, which read: "it is not suitable for us at present".

(Image credit: Mental Floss)


Vladimir Nabokov

Lolita is one of the best-selling novels of all time, with over 50 million copies sold since its debut in 1955, but Vladimir Nabokov had a hard time of finding someone who would agree to publish it. One rejection letter read: "It is overwhelmingly nauseating, even to an enlightened Freudian. To the public, it will be revolting. It will not sell... I recommend that it be buried under a stone for a thousand years."

A letter written by Mrs Blanche Knopf of Alfred A. Knopf, Inc publishing house, thankfully, wasn't as harsh:

(Image credit: Flavorwire.com from the Knopf archives)


Gertrude Stein

The novelist Gertrude Stein is one of the most prominent voices of American Literature. She inspired experimental artists and had literary friends by the likes of F. Scott Fitzgerald and Ernest Hemingway. In fact, it was to Hemingway that Stein coined the phrase "the lost generation" to describe the expatriate writers living abroad between the wars. However, her writing was too dense for Arthur C. Fifield who didn't bother reading the full manuscript for The Making of Americans, sending her the most poetic rejection letter we've seen yet.

(Image credit: Mental Floss)


Jason Segel

Writer and actor Jason Segel revealed to the press that he'd love to work on-screen with Hillary Clinton, saying he felt she had a knack for comedy and claiming she could be the mysterious, titular mother in How I Met Your Mother. Clinton caught wind of Segel's messages and penned him this sweet yet crushing rejection letter:

(Image credit: Politico)

(Words: Sejal Kapadia)

Related

cate-blanchett.jpg

Cate Blanchett wore the most expensive Oscars outfit

rexfeatures-3648123ao.jpg

Scarlett Johansson calls Dylan Farrow's letter irresponsible

hero.jpg

Famous cartoon couples re-imagined in domestic violent scenes

hero.jpg

History's most notorious female criminals

hero.jpg

Female journalists who changed the world

hero.jpg

20 on-screen bedrooms we wish were ours

Comments

Latest...

“A letter to myself on the day I was made redundant”

““Wipe the tears away”

by Kayleigh Dray
29 Nov 2016

Lena Dunham’s powerful post reminds us why we need to take sick days

The Girls star doesn’t want us to ‘soldier on’ through our illnesses

by Kayleigh Dray
28 Nov 2016

Work/Life: a papercutter's one-day diary

Papercutter Poppy Chancellor shares her daily routine, from morning latte to lights out

by  Moya Lothian-McLean
23 Nov 2016

New report names 15 best places to live and work in the UK

Is your hometown on the list?

by Kayleigh Dray
17 Nov 2016

The feminist powerhouses backing Stylist's #EqualPayDay initiative

“I want to do all I can to ensure women have the same opportunities as men in London”

10 Nov 2016

Five steps to finally making that brilliant app idea a reality

One tech entrepreneur explains how she turned her fantasy fashion app into a successful business.

by Moya Crockett
08 Nov 2016

New crowdfunding platform aims to help women-led businesses flourish

iFundWomen is here to bridge the investment gap.

04 Nov 2016

The highest-paid jobs of 2016 have been revealed…

Thinking of switching careers? Pick one of these…

by Kayleigh Dray
02 Nov 2016

The 10 creepiest jobs and careers in the world, according to science

Bad news for writers everywhere…

by Kayleigh Dray
01 Nov 2016

Why are women still being paid less than men?

Stylist investigates ahead on Equal Pay Day, 10 November

by The Stylist web team
31 Oct 2016