Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation

Opera critics spark outrage after calling singer Tara Erraught 'stocky', 'dumpy' and 'chubby'


The opera community has reacted angrily after senior national newspaper critics commented on the size and shape of Irish mezzo-soprano singer Tara Erraught (pictured above, second from right) who performs in Der Rosenkavalier at the Glyndebourne Opera Festival.

Financial Times writer Andrew Clark referred to the singer as "a chubby bundle of puppy-fat", The Independent's Michael Church described her as "a dumpy girl", the Guardian's Andrew Clements called her "stocky" and The Times' Richard Morrison labelled the opera star as "unbelievable, unsightly and unappealing".

Erraught as the character Octavian, far left

Erraught, 27, is considered a rising star in her field having she won widespread acclaim.

The opera world reacted with anger at the disparaging comments against the singer with many taking to the internet to express their views.

Mezzo soprano Jennifer Johnston wrote, "Clearly overt sexism is still rife," in a blog post on the Guardian.

She continued: "There was little comment on her musicianship, dramatic commitment or her ability to communicate to an audience and to move that audience to tears."

Another soprano, Elisabeth Meister, asked, "What on earth does your body size have to do with how well you can sing?" on her blog.

"I’m saddened to see articles that STILL try to tell us women how we should look in order to be attractive, " wrote Meister. "I work in an industry that celebrates the most natural thing a person can possess: the human voice...There are more than enough industries set up around the world to make women feel bad about themselves. We don’t need it in the classical music world too, thank you very much."

Tara Erraught

Others took to Twitter, where Thomas Kohut, a singer with the London Symphony Chorus, wrote "These Der Rosenkavalier reviews really are unacceptable," and Music journalist Elizabeth Davies added, "Some pretty shocking casual sexism in the opera world this morning".

The Telegraph's critic, Rupert Christiansen, has defended his review, saying, "Fat and thin can be equally beautiful but one has to make an audience believe".

He said Erraught's role of Octavian - a male character traditionally played by a woman - called for a "taller" singer who could carry off the "principal-boy type".

However, he added, "I am distressed to learn that Miss Erraught has been upset by the hoo-ha around the reception of her performance".

In response to the furore, Glyndebourne issued a statement saying, "Tara Erraught is an outstandingly talented young artist whom we are thrilled to have as part of the cast of Der Rosenkavalier."

Erraught, so far, has not commented on the negative reviews.



New Kickstarter encourages women to love their bodies just as they are


Missing US woman found after 10 years in captivity


5 films wowing the critics at Cannes


Lucy Mangan: "Mothers are being written out of history"


Russian wife awarded £2.7 billion in highest ever divorce settlement


Angelina Jolie on nerves, chaos and working with Brad Pitt



“How beauty rituals help me manage my depression”

One writer found comfort in an unexpected place

21 Oct 2016

Stress is genuinely good for you, experts reveal

Forget everything you thought you knew about stress…

by Kayleigh Dray
21 Oct 2016

Must-watch Christmas TV: tune in for Roald Dahl's Revolting Rhymes

Just in time for Christmas

by Sarah Biddlecombe
21 Oct 2016

Bake Off fans, the BBC has already found a replacement show for GBBO

And it's set to hit our televisions very soon...

by Kayleigh Dray
21 Oct 2016

Costa’s fancy new menu includes avocado toast and Prosecco

You may want to dress up for the world’s poshest Costa…

by Kayleigh Dray
21 Oct 2016

Real-life victims of revenge porn share their stories

“Within a week, everyone had seen them… I tried to kill myself shortly after”

by Kayleigh Dray
21 Oct 2016

People diagnosed with a terminal illness share powerful life lessons

“You only get one life – and we need to live it”

by Kayleigh Dray
21 Oct 2016

This gin is officially the best in Europe – and it's from the UK

Gin drinkers, take note…

by Kayleigh Dray
21 Oct 2016

Amazing tasting menus from top UK restaurants for under £50

Total steals from Michelin-starred spots

by Amy Swales
20 Oct 2016

9 hilarious tips for making it in a male-dominated workplace

"Never say anything that sounds like a question, even questions."

by Harriet Hall
20 Oct 2016