Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation

This is why you probably shouldn’t have an argument in front of your dog

dog dislike people.jpg

Dog owners have long suspected that their canine companions have stellar instincts for more than just where the nearest snack is – whether that’s making a beeline for the person most in need of comfort or their complete refusal to acknowledge a cooing stranger’s presence despite their usually desperate need for attention.

And with the latter, if your dog doesn’t trust someone, you tend to join him in a bit of side-eye.

Now a study has backed up the idea that dogs can recognise and remember when people are unpleasant.

The research, published in Neuroscience & Biobehavioural Reviews, looked into “reactions to people who are helpful or unhelpful in third-party contexts” and found that dogs were so not into people they’d seen being mean-spirited that they’d rather take a treat from a passive bystander than from someone who is actively unhelpful.

Read more: This is why dog ownership is so life-enhancing

With studies having shown that by the age of one, babies are already judging how people interact, comparative psychologist James Anderson of Kyoto University decided to look into how dogs and monkeys use information about the interactions they witness.

The team asked dog owners to pretend to struggle with opening a box in front of their pet. Each time, two actors were also present. The owner would ask one of them for help and the actor would either help them or refuse. The second actor would always remain passive and not be a part of the interaction. Both of the actors would then offer the dog a treat.

As seen in the New Scientist video above, in the first instance, when the actor helped the owner open the box, the dogs didn’t care and would take a treat from either actor without showing preference. In the second instance, however – the one in which the actor actively refused to help and turned their head away – the dogs were more likely to ignore them and go to the passive researcher.

While previous studies indicate that a dog’s ‘instant’ dislike of someone is probably based on your own interactions and reaction to that person, these results suggest that dogs also do not like or trust someone they have witnessed being a bit of an arse for themselves. Which has made us think twice about arguing in front of the pooch...

Speaking to New Scientist, Anderson said he thinks the results show that the monkeys and dogs evaluate people in a similar way to human infants: “If somebody is behaving antisocially, they probably end up with some sort of emotional reaction to it.”

Thanks to our long and unique relationship with dogs (going back thousands of years, in fact), it’s no wonder they can pick things up from you Derren Brown-style before you’ve even fully decided whether you’re getting up to fetch the lead.

And now, we’re even more inclined to trust their judgement. So sorry guy in the pub who apparently doesn’t have a dog but for some reason has a pocketful of Bonios, he ain’t taking your treat.

Images: iStock


Pit Bull.JPG

Patrick Stewart on the power of rescue dogs


Why is dog ownership so life enhancing?


Science has very good news for people who talk to their pets...


Ireland will hold a referendum on abortion in 2018

Here’s everything you need to know about what could be a landmark moment for women’s rights

by Moya Crockett
26 Sep 2017

29 autumn tattoos that capture the magic of the golden season

Think woodland illustrations and sunset hues

by Megan Murray
26 Sep 2017

The greatest life lessons from The Princess Bride

It's been 30 years since it first hit the big screen

by Susan Devaney
26 Sep 2017

These are the four skills you should highlight on your CV

According to the world's top CEOs

by Helen Brown
26 Sep 2017

This woman’s post encourages others to call out sexual harassment

“He tilted his phone up... enough for me to see the picture of my ass”

by Amy Swales
26 Sep 2017

Trump rates Angelina Jolie and Anne Hathaway in newly released tapes

“I don’t think she’s got good skin. I don’t think she’s got a great face.”

by Amy Swales
26 Sep 2017

Depressingly, this TV moment attracted the most complaints of 2017

Don’t we all have bigger things to worry about than this?

by Kayleigh Dray
26 Sep 2017

This TV show has been voted reigning champion of the last 20 years

And no, it's not Friends

by Megan Murray
26 Sep 2017

Everything you need to know about Pretty Woman: The Musical

We already can’t wait for this

by Moya Crockett
26 Sep 2017

Why you'll never fancy that person who REALLY likes you

According to experts

by Nicola Colyer
26 Sep 2017