Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation
Top

As The Sun announces Page Three has not been retired, take a look at the strongest arguments for and against

Page three returns.jpg

On Tuesday, The Times  reported that its sister paper, tabloid newspaper The Sun, had quietly retired the infamous Page Three slot, which depicts a topless woman, after publishing it for 45 years.

Many, including Stylist, supported (and still support) this decision. What's more, it was a real victory for the No More Page Three campaigners, headed up by  Lucy-Anne Holmes, who set up an online petition in August 2012, with the aim to ban the images as they were too sexual for a family newspaper. 

The campaign had received over 200,000 signatures on its petition so understandably many were euphoric over the matter, such as celebrities, journalists and the campaigners:

Russell Brand also came forward in support of the campaign, and even posted up a video of himself explaining why this is a step in the right direction for women's rights.

But while many celebrated, others were angry about the decision and suggested that this move actually restricted women's rights. 

In a piece on The Independent's i100 website, in which they asked glamour models their views, one-time Page Three model Chloe Goodman had this to say on the matter:

“Why should feminist women then tell other women how to live their lives? Women fought together to get the vote and so on and so forth, so why should women now be fighting each other, and tell each other what job roles to now take within the industry?”

Writing for The Debrief, columnist also Katie Glass made an interesting point: 

“In the same way, we women shouldn’t lump ourselves together. We are not homogenous! One woman doing something does not represent us all. We can run the gamut - be journalists, doctors, firefighters, barristers, glamour models. We’re individuals, not just gender - that’s what real equality is.”

In the Guardian, female writers were asked their oinion on The Sun's decision. 

MP Stella Creasy made a great point with this comment: 

"This has never about being "offended" by Page 3, but being affected by it. By highlighting how so many felt about women's bodies being objectified, this campaign has prompted national debate on the kind of message we send to 51% of the population about their role in our society. Telling someone to turn the page misses the point about the culture that this depiction of what is valued about women feeds. That even when we don't look we are impacted by its presence."

But that victory was short-lived, as today The Sun has published yet another Page Three model, with a young woman baring her breasts. As if that wasn't insulting enough for those who campaigned against it, the tabloid's smug caption added salt to the wound.

The Sun

Clearly, as shown by a tweet from The Sun's head of press Dylan Sharpe, it appears to be little more than a publicity campaign.

Obviously, many were saddened and angered by the news:

One of the commenters in the Guardian today summed it up perfectly:

Comments Page Three Guardian.co.uk

Most depressingly, it feels like there's a renewed struggle on speaking out against Page Three with women being vilified for expressing their disgust at The Sun's behaviour.

But perhaps journalist Sali Hughes' tweet sums it up the best for us:

Tell us whether you think Page Three should be banned by voting in our poll.

Even better, let us know your thoughts in the comments below or tweet us at @stylistmagazine

Related

Top know HERO.jpg

Five quick hairstyles to save you time in the morning

84382399.jpg

New Invisible Boyfriend app lets you fake a relationship

78495532.jpg

10 slick gadgets and apps for a healthier and fitter you

Comments

More

Samantha Baines: “It’s time to leave our vaginas the hell alone”

The Call the Midwife star has her say on vaginal beauty treatments

by Kayleigh Dray
26 May 2017

Ramadan: The best places to break your fast in London

These London restaurants provide late night openings and special iftar menus

26 May 2017

10-year-old survivor’s letter to Ariana Grande is beyond beautiful

“I really hope you’re not too scared”

by Kayleigh Dray
26 May 2017

It’s official: this easy email hack is guaranteed to boost read rates

Make your emails stand out in your recipient's inbox with one simple trick

by Jasmine Andersson
26 May 2017

Fathers pay more attention to daughters than sons, new study shows

Dads are also "more emotionally engaged" with girls

by Anna Brech
26 May 2017

Men are totally devastated by this women-only Wonder Woman screening

Who knew they were such big fans of Diana Prince?

by Moya Crockett
26 May 2017

Dog breaks into studio to help reporter read the news

The internet is obsessed with this live news blooper (and for good reason)

by Kayleigh Dray
26 May 2017

“Get over yourself”: gymnast hits back at stranger who judged her arms

Alexandra Raisman responds to “rude and uncomfortable” incident

by Anna Brech
26 May 2017

Fighting for their rights: the heroic teens battling period taboos

"I wasn’t allowed to comb my hair, look in the mirror, attend school, read and write."

by Sarah Biddlecombe
25 May 2017

Twitter responds to terror threat level the only way it knows how

#BritishThreatLevels showcases the self-deprecating humour we Brits seem to love

by Amy Swales
25 May 2017