Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation
Top

“It was called hunger when we were young”: Joan Bakewell sparks outrage with comments on 'narcissistic' anorexia

rexfeatures_1455991k.jpg

Broadcaster Joan Bakewell sparked outrage yesterday with a series of comments about eating disorders.

The 82-year-old Labour peer said anorexia was "called hunger when we were young. You sat and ate until your plate was clean." She also described eating disorders as stemming from "narcissism" and "overindulgence".

Speaking to The Sunday Times, Bakewell said, "I am alarmed by anorexia among young people, which arises presumably because they are preoccupied with being beautiful and healthy and thin.

"No one has anorexia in societies where there is not enough food. They do not have anorexia in the camps in Syria. I think it's possible anorexia could be about narcissism."

anorexia

Bakewell is chair of the judging panel for the Wellcome Book Prize, the UK's leading prize for medical, health and illness books.

She continued, "To be unhappy because you are the wrong weight is a sign of the overindulgence of our society, over-introspection, narcissism, really."

Her comments caused a huge reaction on Twitter, with users taking to the social media site to slam Bakewell's lack of understanding of eating disorders.

Representatives from anorexia charities were also quick to criticise Bakewell's comments, with Jane Smith, chief executive of the charity Anorexia and Bulimia Care, describing them as “uninformed".

Speaking to The Daily Telegraph, Smith said, "Although I welcome informed debate on this subject, I am disappointed that people still feel able to suggest a sweeping generalization, without fact, which perpetuates the misconceptions about eating disorders, thereby limiting the understanding for those struggling."

The number of teenagers with eating disorders being admitted to hospital almost doubling in the last three years.

Kate Nightingale, head of communications at mental health charity Time to Change, voiced her concern to The Daily Telegraph.

She said, “The stigma and misunderstanding surrounding these issues only makes life harder for people going through them - so what we need is increased understanding and support.”

anorexia

Bakewell herself initially took to Twitter to say, "I've stirred a public debate about anorexia... Good."

However, she soon apologised for the comments and said last night that she was "deeply sorry".

Related

anxious child.jpg

“My childhood anxiety went untreated - and I'm still dealing with it”

anna wyatt.JPG

The random act of kindness that helped this woman overcome anorexia

amalie lee instagram recovery.JPG

Woman documents her recovery from anorexia on Instagram

emma watson heforshe gender equality speech forest whitaker arts week.jpg

‘Photographers laid on the pavement and took photographs up my skirt’

daisy ridley.jpg

Daisy Ridley responds to body shamers on Instagram

Alice_166.jpg

“How my battle with cancer transformed my body confidence”

12745951_10208899146341904_887766559090185939_n.jpg

Mum uses lingerie model to shut down breastfeeding complaints

rexfeatures_5231368cq.jpg

Cara Delevingne pens open letter on success and happiness

nat geo penguin

Penguin swims 5,000 miles a year to visit the man who saved his life

Comments

More

March for a more equal world

Your essential guide to making your voice heard this Saturday

by The Stylist web team
17 Jan 2017

Everything you need to know about the Women’s March on London

From where to meet to what to wear.

by Moya Crockett
17 Jan 2017

Gossiping is good for you, study suggests

We knew it.

by Sarah Biddlecombe
17 Jan 2017

Family celebrate little girl’s first period in a very unique way

“My family is super extra”

by Kayleigh Dray
17 Jan 2017

Tampon sales in the UK have plummeted dramatically, but why?

New figures show that women in the UK are buying five million fewer packets of tampons each year.

by Harriet Hall
17 Jan 2017

Expert tips on making your money last through January

How to survive the leanest month

by The Stylist web team
17 Jan 2017

More men cry after a work performance review than women, study finds

22% of us cry following a review

by Sarah Biddlecombe
17 Jan 2017

First Dates fans praise woman who witnessed husband's murder

“I told myself that I had to be happy because I knew that’s what he’d want for me”

by Kayleigh Dray
17 Jan 2017

Turbo G&T is the new gin trend taking over our Instagram feeds

Gin lovers, pay attention…

by Kayleigh Dray
16 Jan 2017

Politician arrested for grabbing a woman's groin - sound familiar?

Sound familiar?

by Anna Pollitt
16 Jan 2017