Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation
Top

A man has been cleared of sexual assault because he didn’t ‘enjoy’ it

veracruz-mexico-los-porkys-rape-case-sexual-assault-cleared-2.jpg

A Mexican man has been cleared of sexually assaulting a schoolgirl after a judge ruled that he did not enjoy himself.

Diego Cruz Alonso, 21, was found not guilty of assault by Judge Anuar González on Monday, the Guardian reports.

Cruz and three other young men were accused of abducting a 17-year-old girl as she left a New Year’s Eve party in January 2015. All four men came from prominent families in Veracruz, a coastal state on the Gulf of Mexico, and the girl was a fellow student at their elite private school.

The judge ruled that while Cruz was accused of touching the victim’s breasts and penetrating her with his fingers, he was not guilty of sexual assault because he had acted without “carnal intent”.

The girl had claimed that she was forced into a black Mercedes owned by one of Cruz’s friends, Enrique Capitaine Marin, while waiting for a friend to pick her up from outside a Veracruz club. (The car had been a birthday gift from Capitaine’s father, a wealthy Veracruz businessman and politician.)


Read more: Rape victims will now be spared the trauma of giving evidence in court


While in the car, the girl said, she was assaulted by Cruz and another man, Jorge Cotaita Cabrales. She was then driven to Capitaine’s house, where he allegedly raped her. After the incident, Cruz is thought to have called the girl’s friends to come and collect her.

Judge González acknowledged that the girl had been forced into a car, and her claims of assault. In clearing Cruz of sexual assault charges, however, he said that he did not believe that the girl had been “helpless” as she claimed.

veracruz

Veracruz, where Diego Cruz Alonso has been cleared of sexual assault.

Estefania Vela Barba, a women’s rights activist who works in the legal studies department at Mexico’s Centre for Teaching and Research in Economics, says while Cruz may have taken no “pleasure” in the alleged sexual assault, he certainly intended to “humiliate” the girl.


Read more: Rape survivor says judge was “right” to warn women about drunkenness


“They were touching her, they were bothering her, [but] for the judge, if the intention wasn’t pleasure, it’s not sexual assault,” Vela tells the Guardian.

She adds: “It’s coming from the judge’s mouth… He’s saying that if they touch you against your will, it [nevertheless] might not be abuse.”


Watch: Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie wants a feminist world


The case has sparked huge controversy in Mexico, where Cruz and the three other men were nicknamed ‘Los Porkys’ on social media. Judge González’s decision has been interpreted as further proof that the wealthy and well-connected can escape justice – particularly in Veracruz, which already has a reputation for corruption and lawlessness.

The girl’s father, a therapist, told the New Yorker last year that he never expected the men to be punished by the law.

“In Mexico, the last thing the system of justice provides is justice,” he said, adding that he “just didn’t trust the authorities… I knew they would fail us.”

The girl herself, who no longer lives in Mexico and suffers extreme anxiety attacks, has also experienced victim-blaming. The men’s attorney, Edgar Cinta, aggressively challenged her version of events, telling a local television channel that “she says her underwear was pulled down to her ankles, but then she has to spread her legs. I want to know how she did it”. Her supposed “promiscuity” and drinking were also claimed to invalidate her claims of sexual assault.

In an impassioned post on Facebook, the girl tore into the victim-blaming she had faced.

“I’m not hiding,” she wrote. “I’m not saying anything but the truth. I have nothing to repent.”

Images: Rex Features, Getty Images

Related

Operner_rt.jpg

Discover the tribe in western China where women hold all the power

yezidi-women-captured-isis-escaped-photography-benjamin-eagle.jpg

Female ISIS survivors on love, grief and the power of endurance

argentina-protest-lucia-perez-murder-MiercolesNegro-2.jpg

Argentinian women take to the streets after teenage girl is murdered

More

The deadly secret hidden within that creepy Game of Thrones hug

Spoilers are coming…

by Kayleigh Dray
18 Aug 2017

Why it’s totally fine if you don’t have a ‘work wife’

Having friends at work is nice – but it’s not the be all and end all

by Moya Crockett
18 Aug 2017

Meteorologist’s epic response to troll who called her “disgusting”

“Enough is enough.”

by Sarah Biddlecombe
18 Aug 2017

Acts of love, humanity and solidarity following the Barcelona attack

In the darkness, there is light.

by Moya Crockett
18 Aug 2017

How you can help those caught up in the Barcelona attack

The ways you can support the victims, survivors and investigation

by Kayleigh Dray
18 Aug 2017

People are furious about Trump’s response to the Barcelona attack

The world is sick of his double-standard on terrorism

by Kayleigh Dray
18 Aug 2017

Ryan Phillipe on how he tackles depression

“I’m thinking about how to focus and steady myself”

by Susan Devaney
17 Aug 2017

Are black girls being forced to grow up too fast?

A study has shown that black girls as young as five are seen as more adult than their white peers

by Kemi Alemoru
17 Aug 2017

Teen receives sickening messages after asking for career advice

This businessman's response was shocking

by Sarah Biddlecombe
17 Aug 2017

We want everything from this new high-street Disney collaboration

Seriously magical

by Megan Murray
17 Aug 2017