Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation

“Why Love Island’s Olivia was 100% right to dump the nice guy”

love island olivia chris breakup villa nice guys.jpg

Anyone who’s ever been in a relationship will find something to relate to on Love Island.

The nation’s favourite show has a penchant for putting couples through their paces and throwing in the odd game changer or two (think new love interests entering the villa or a partner being snapped up by someone else during a recoupling) all of which makes for seriously addictive, cancel-all-your-plans type viewing.

And last night’s episode was no exception, as it tackled a topic most of us are painfully familiar with – heartbreak.

There were tears – and outbursts of rage – up and down the country as we watched Olivia finally end things with Chris because, ultimately, he always “wants to be the nice guy”.

The catalyst for the moment came as Chris made an effort to comfort their fellow housemate, Tyla, following the departure of her love interest, Jonny. However, Olivia herself was feeling upset at being voted in the villa’s bottom four contestants by the public, and thought he should have comforted her instead.

Slamming his lack of loyalty, she drew a line under their relationship and finally ended days of arguing between the pair.

Which you might think sounds fair enough – but you would be wrong.

Chris and Olivia officially put an end to "Chrolivia" in last night's Love Island

Chris and Olivia officially put an end to "Chrolivia" in last night's Love Island

Furious Love Island fans took to Twitter to vent their rage at Olivia, all for the crime of daring to break up with a bona fide “nice guy”.

“Olivia is like one of those mean girls at school. Targeting people for just being nice,” wrote one user.

“Olivia is the perfect example of a narcissist!! What an awful person...” added another.

But before we condemn Olivia entirely just for having the nerve to end a relationship that wasn’t making her happy, perhaps we should take a step back and imagine ourselves in a similar position.

After all, does stumbling upon a nice guy mean we should grab hold of him and never let him go, no matter how awful he makes us feel? Should we be prepared to “walk on egg shells” and push down certain aspects of our personality for the rest of our lives, just for the privilege of being with a person who pays us the odd compliment or two and brings us breakfast in bed?

Absolutely not.

Read more: This writer has nailed everything that’s wrong with The Friend Zone

As someone who has taken the “risk” of breaking up with a real life nice guy before, I have no problem relating to Olivia’s desire to put herself first for a change. And I call breaking up with said nice guy a “risk” because society seems to view such men as a rarity that should be held up as the most precious possession a woman could ever hope to own, and the pathway to all future happiness, etc. etc.

I can still remember the shocked reactions of my friends when I told them about the break up, with the main cause for concern seeming to be that I might not find a man as nice as the one I had just let go. I was alternately told I was being too picky, or indulging the perfectionist side of my personality, and in the initial few weeks after the relationship ended I panicked that I had made a big mistake.

But ultimately, what I learnt from the experience was this: nice guy or not, if someone doesn’t make you happy, they don’t make you happy – and if you’re not happy, then what on earth is the point?

Nice guys aren't always worth it

Nice guys aren't always worth it

And it seems that psychology is in agreement with me. In an article (brilliantly) titled Four Reasons Not To Settle In A Relationship, Dr Juliana Breines makes the case for following your heart in a relationship, rather than bowing to societal pressures and sticking it out with someone you know isn’t quite right for you.

“Settling is an ugly, depressing word,” she writes. “Few people would suggest outright that you should settle for less than you want and deserve in a relationship.”

Read more: What that Love Island row can teach us about dating as a feminist

She goes on to outline the four reasons we should never settle, by listing the benefits of being single, the importance of recognising which shortcomings we can accept in our partners and how the chance of finding true love could be worth the risk of never finding it at all.

Chris and Olivia in happier times

Chris and Olivia in happier times

Most intriguingly, however, she references a set of scientific studies that found people who had a fear of being single were more likely to prioritise being in any relationship over being in no relationship at all. In other words, their fear of being alone lowered their standards to the point that they would prefer to be in a bad relationship than be by themselves.

“Given the importance of social connection to our well-being, it is understandable that we seek out intimate relationships,” Breines writes.

“But when fear of being alone drives our romantic decisions, it can lead us to exercise poor judgment and to choose relationships that are unlikely to last, that make us depressed, or even leave us vulnerable to abuse.”

It’s a valid point, and one that sits perfectly in line with the idea that you can never be happy in a relationship if you can’t be happy by yourself.

To which I say – life is too short for beige relationships with nice guys who don’t set your heart on fire. Take that risk and swap being 70% happy for the opportunity to upgrade to 100%.

Be more Olivia, and put yourself first before you commit to a lifetime of the most boring word in the English dictionary.

Images: Rex Features


love island amber olivia.jpg

Love Island 2017: insider reveals what goes on behind the scenes

love island camilla.jpg

People are furious with Love Island, for an unexpected reason

gabby love island.jpg

“Love Island exposed our misconceptions about anxiety and insecurity”


Elisabeth Moss isn’t done with powerful dramas about women’s rights

Call Jane is set to be as relevant for Trump's America as its 60s setting

by Amy Swales
20 Sep 2017

Why we all think we’re the least popular one in our group of friends

If you believe everyone’s hanging out without you, you’re not alone

by Moya Crockett
20 Sep 2017

Why that Doctor Foster conversation is so incredibly important

We really need to talk about last night’s episode…

by Kayleigh Dray
20 Sep 2017

What is panic disorder – and do you suffer from it?

Nadiya Hussain described it as a 'monster'

by Megan Murray
20 Sep 2017

This is the one thing people would rather have than a pay rise

And it makes us a lot happier

by Susan Devaney
20 Sep 2017

Nutella's newest product sounds like all kinds of deliciousness

Nutella feasting can now happen any time, any place

by Megan Murray
20 Sep 2017

Man recreates Chandler proposal so he can ask Friends fan to marry him

And he did it in the actual Friends apartment, too

by Kayleigh Dray
20 Sep 2017

Bake Off viewers are genuinely furious over THAT ‘shock twist’ ending

“Is there no justice in this world?”

by Kayleigh Dray
20 Sep 2017

Students told to submit dresses for approval ahead of school dance

“These are the roots of rape culture, frankly”

by Amy Swales
19 Sep 2017

This is why hardly any men are taking shared parental leave in the UK

Women are still doing the lion’s share of childcare, while men go out to work

by Moya Crockett
19 Sep 2017