Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation

Love Island contestant denounced by abuse charity for “possessive, controlling” behaviour

jonny love island cold dead hands tyla.jpg

Domestic abuse, both physical and emotional, is not as black and white as one might believe – the filmic idea of a drunk husband coming home from the pub and blacking his wife’s eye for not doing the washing up cannot and does not represent every survivor’s experience.

Charities have long highlighted how domestic abuse can take the form of emotional manipulation and controlling behaviour – something officially recognised in the UK in 2015, with the introduction of a law specifically targeting “controlling or coercive behaviour”.

Now the CEO of Women’s Aid has taken aim at ‘banter’ – the catch-all term that too often allows people to say whatever they like, however offensive, under the guise of ‘just having a laugh’ – and specifically, at a comment from a Love Island contestant.

In an episode aired Monday 10 June, Jonny Mitchell remarked that a newcomer to the show, Theo Campbell, would have to prise contestant Tyra Carr from his “cold, dead hands”.

tyla theo love island

Campbell discusses Michell's behaviour with Carr

In a statement released on the Women’s Aid website, CEO Polly Neate said this type of comment revealed problematic ideas of ownership which paint a woman as a possession, not a person.

“When Jonny said that new arrival Theo would have to prise Tyla ‘from my cold dead hands’ it was not romantic,” she says. “It did not demonstrate just how much he liked her. It was possessive and controlling.

“What can be all too easily passed off as banter, actually carries the underlying sentiment that this man believes he owns this woman.”

Read more: Woman’s text messages reveal the daily controlling behaviour of abusers

Campbell and Mitchell had clashed earlier when Campbell had chosen Carr in the ‘recoupling’, prompting a heated exchange between the men.

In the episode, available on ITV Player, new contestant Campbell is heard commenting on Mitchell, telling Carr: “I believe he [Jonny] is on you 24/7. To me that shows how insecure he is at the moment and to not even let you out of his grasp or out of his sight, and he’s losing his head.”

Attempting to listen in on the conversation, Mitchell then states out of earshot of Campbell: “He’ll have her to pry her out of my cold, dead hands.”

At one point, the voiceover helpfully adds: “Yeah Jonny, take a chill pill. It’s not like the first thing Tyla’s gonna do is run off with Theo. It’s the second thing – after she’s put on some fresh lippy.”

Read more: “Love Island just proved why it's always OK to break up with a nice guy”

Neate goes on to say that “sexist remarks” such as Mitchell’s must be challenged at every opportunity.

She writes: “All of us have a duty to call out this sort of behaviour and challenge these sexist remarks when we hear them.

“The fact that Tyla says she was left wanting to run away from a controlling relationship in the past, shows just how easy this sort of behaviour, if unchecked, can slip into a controlling and abusive relationship.”

In the episode, Campbell makes a similar point telling Carr: “If he can lose his head that easily, imagine like you go to a club or something and you’re getting a photo with another boy and that, he’s gonna lose his s*** with you […] He’s not gonna be any different outside.”

jonny mitchell love island cold dead hands

Mitchell said Campbell would have to prise Carr from his "cold, dead hands"

It’s now acknowledged that psychological torment – jealousy, obsessiveness, constant contact, limiting interaction with friends, controlling finances, online spying – can be as destructive as physical abuse.

Read more: Kerry Washington shines a light on the role money plays in domestic abuse

Women’s Aid defines domestic abuse as an incident or pattern of incidents of controlling, coercive, threatening, degrading and violent behaviour, including sexual violence, in the majority of cases by a partner or ex-partner, but also by a family member or carer.

Domestic abuse can include, but is not limited to, the following:

  • Coercive control (a pattern of intimidation, degradation, isolation and control with the use or threat of physical or sexual violence)
  • Psychological and/or emotional abuse
  • Physical abuse
  • Sexual abuse
  • Financial abuse
  • Harassment
  • Stalking
  • Online or digital abuse

The Freephone 24 Hour National Domestic Violence Helpline, run in partnership between Women's Aid and Refuge, is a national service for women experiencing domestic violence, their family, friends, colleagues and others calling on their behalf. Call 0808 2000 247 or visit nationaldomesticviolencehelpline.org.uk.

Images: ITV2 / Rex Features


love island amber olivia.jpg

Love Island 2017: insider reveals what goes on behind the scenes

gabby love island.jpg

“Love Island exposed our misconceptions about anxiety and insecurity”


What that Love Island row can teach us about dating as a feminist


The most annoying Tube habits, as ranked by irritated Londoners

“Could you move down, please?”

by Amy Swales
22 Aug 2017

These are the main reasons relationships end, according to a new study

...and the reasons couples stay together

by Megan Murray
22 Aug 2017

The new Great British Bake Off might be OK after all

The first episode has not bombed, we repeat: it has not bombed

by Amy Swales
22 Aug 2017

Woman claims she was fired for leaking during a heavy period at work

“Every woman dreads getting period symptoms when they're not expecting them, but I never thought I could be fired for it.”

by Sarah Biddlecombe
22 Aug 2017

Women football fans forced to show bras while being searched at match

Add this to your list of ‘things that are definitely not OK’

by Moya Crockett
22 Aug 2017

This prosecco advent calendar will have you waving goodbye to summer

We're suddenly very excited about Christmas

by Megan Murray
22 Aug 2017

Heartfelt letter on coping with an anxious partner goes viral

“Anxiety isn't a one size fits all, it isn't consistent and it isn't always easy to tell”

by Sarah Biddlecombe
22 Aug 2017

Why India banning instant divorce is a major victory for women

India’s Supreme Court has ruled against triple talaq, which allowed Muslim men to instantly divorce their wives.

by Moya Crockett
22 Aug 2017

The mental health storyline you never noticed on Game of Thrones

An incredibly powerful character arc you might have missed

by Kayleigh Dray
22 Aug 2017

“Why I opted out of reconstruction after my double mastectomy”

Breast cancer survivor Jeanne Paul says many don’t understand her choice

by Amy Swales
21 Aug 2017