Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation

Naked breasts are more French than the veil, says Prime Minister


The highest court in France recently ruled that the controversial burkini ban could not be enforced, stating that doing so would violate “the freedom of beliefs and individual freedom”.

But if you thought that meant the debate over what women can wear to the beach was over, you were sorely mistaken. One man is determined to keep the burkini row rumbling on and on: the French Prime Minister, Manuel Valls.

In a fiery speech at a rally on Monday night, Valls argued that the veil worn by Muslim women contradicts French national values, stating that the naked breasts of Marianne – a national symbol of the French Republic, adopted during the French Revolution – represent freedom.

“Marianne has a naked breast because she is feeding the people! She is not veiled, because she is free!” Valls reportedly told supporters. “That is the Republic!”


Manuel Valls, France's Socialist PM, has been an outspoken advocate of the burkini ban.

His comments reignited debate about the burkini ban online.

Left-wing French historian Mathilde Larrere tweeted: “Marianne has a bare breast because it’s an allegory, you cretin!”

She added: “Marianne in the nude was an allegory of the 19th century, when the Civil Code reduced women to the status of minors and barred them from voting.”

Larrere also pointed out that artistic depictions of Marianne have not always shown her bare-breasted. Often, rather, she is shown wearing a Phrygian cap – a head covering symbolising freedom and the pursuit of liberty, thanks to its resemblance to caps worn by emancipated slaves in ancient Rome. 

Other Twitter users observed that today, Marianne would be just as likely to be arrested for public indecency as a woman wearing a burkini.


A bust of Marianne displayed in the corridors of the Luxembourg Palace, the seat of the French Senate, showing her wearing a Phrygian cap.

Valls has been a high-profile supporter of the burkini ban, introduced by around 30 French mayors under the pretext of protecting the country against further terror attacks.

“For me the burkini is a symbol of the enslavement of women,” he said in an interview in August, adding that France was locked in a “battle of cultures”.

He had previously told reporters that he viewed the burkini as “the expression of a political project, a counter-society, based notably on the enslavement of women.”

Read more: Burkini inventor pens powerful essay on French ban

However, Cécile Duflot, a former Green party minister in France, said that Valls’ praise of Marianne’s bare breasts was indicative of the way some French male politicians viewed women.

Most of the burkini restrictions were enforced in the southeast of France, an area home to a high proportion of immigrants and where far-right politics have gained a firm foothold. Despite the higher courts’ ruling against the burkini ban, some mayors have said that they still plan on enforcing the rule.

Images: Getty, Wikimedia Commons



Highest court in France suspends burkini ban

burkini 1.jpg

British retailer launches burkini range for Muslim women


Burkini designer pens powerful essay on French ban


French beauty blogger speaks out against Nice terror attack

nick alexander bataclan.jpg

Woman tells how “love of her life” died in her arms in Paris attack

adele terror.jpg

Adele pays tribute to Brussels terror victims at London concert


Instagram has fallen in love with heart-shaped succulents

The millennial houseplant obsession continues

by Helen Brown
25 Sep 2017

How many of our favourite First Dates couples are still together?

Here’s a look at the couples living happily ever after…

by Kayleigh Dray
25 Sep 2017

The sad reason this type of rescue dog is the most overlooked

Open your hearts, people

by Amy Swales
25 Sep 2017

What is diabulimia? The dangerous disorder in need of a spotlight

A lack of awareness means sufferers could be flying under the radar

by Amy Swales
25 Sep 2017

This is how your friends’ bad moods can affect your own mental health

A new study sheds light on how we ‘pick up’ emotions from our friends

by Moya Crockett
25 Sep 2017

Women have a new word for that annoying thing your male colleague does

Forget mansplaining: there's a new word in town

by Helen Brown
25 Sep 2017

Will & Grace fans, Debra Messing's character has changed in a big way

And we’re on board

by Susan Devaney
25 Sep 2017

Instagram creates automatic Facebook post saying “I will rape you”

How to win friends and influence people?

by Moya Crockett
25 Sep 2017

This Netflix horror about ghostly ex revenge is perfect Halloween TV

This looks absolutely terrifying

by Kayleigh Dray
25 Sep 2017

Sign up to our mouth-watering food and drink email

24 Sep 2017