Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation
Top

Posting inspirational quotes linked to lower levels of intelligence, science says

marilynhero.jpg

We've all done it. Found an inspirational message that's made us smile, laugh or reaffirmed our beliefs so much we've wanted to re-post it and share it ourselves. Such quotes are the staple of every social media feed.

But they may be less so now a study out this week has found that people who share profound declarations on social media tend to be less intelligent.

The research, with its cut-to-the-chase title On the reception and detection of pseudo-profound bulls***t  found that people who are more receptive to such quotes get lower scores in cognitive tests. They are also more prone to believing in the paranormal, hold religious beliefs and are taken in by conspiracy theories.

Vindication for anyone who has ever un-friended and un-followed someone who is constantly posting upbeat mottos on their Twitter and Facebook feeds then, it seems.  

 

From my book #SuperGenes with Rudy Tanzi.

A photo posted by Deepak Chopra (@deepakchopra) on

During four experiments involving 845 volunteers, participants were asked to evaluate a series of statements to indicate how profound they thought they were or if they agreed with them. 

Many of the quotes used in the test were posted on Twitter by author and New Age guru Deepak Chopra, who describes himself as a Citizen of the Cosmos. 

Researchers mixed statements that deliberately blended together buzzwords into meaningless sentences and mundane statements that could also be considered profound.

In a follow-up test, the researchers also asked the participants to perform a series of cognitive tests. 

In one they asked them if they agreed with a series of statements about religion, the paranormal or conspiracy theories.

From my new book #SuperGenes with Rudy Tanzi.

A photo posted by Deepak Chopra (@deepakchopra) on

Writing in the journal, Judgment and Decision Making, lead researcher Gordon Pennycook, a cognitive psychologist at the University of Waterloo, in Ontario, explains: “Those more receptive to bulls**t are less reflective, lower in cognitive ability - numeracy, verbal and fluid intelligence, are more prone to ontological confusions and conspiratorial ideation, are more likely to hold religious and paranormal beliefs, and are more likely to endorse complementary and alternative medicine.”

After the paper was published, Professor Brian Cox posted a link to it on Deepak's Twitter feed. 

He responded by saying: “Brian good for you. No resistance, no anticipation, no regrets - just this moment as it is is also my motto.'

He later added: “S**t of any kind is profound. It is stardust and recycles as life. Of all people you should know.”

The trend to post inspirational quotes has also led to a backlash of copycat social media sites which post parodies of them. The Instagram site Uninspirational specialises in posting more real messages - like the one below -  to counteract the deluge of motivational messages out there.  

 

#thank #you @theyearofelan

A photo posted by Unspirational (@unspirational) on

#pineapple

A photo posted by Unspirational (@unspirational) on

Do it. @oneoeight.tv #kindness

A photo posted by Rachel Brathen (@yoga_girl) on

Related

image32.jpg

The 10 most popular Instagram photos of 2015 are all by women

ThinkstockPhotos-187401190.jpg

“Attractive women are more likely to succeed” A debate on body image

selfie-mum-2.jpg

Watch what happens when mums recreate their daughters' selfies

rexfeatures_3737302e.jpg

Science has good news for women with four or more tattoos

Pram.jpg

Parents are naming their children after Instagram filters

1970_MARZO.jpg

Pirelli calendar archives: The most provocative images

adele.jpg

Our guide to securing an Adele ticket this Friday

lion king.jpg

Good news Disney fanatics: there’s now a dating site just for you

reese witherspoon.jpg

Reese Witherspoon signs onto Barbie film

Comments

More

Are you ready for the ultimate gin and gingerbread masterclass?

Lessons take place in a luxury spa, if that helps to seal the deal…

by Kayleigh Dray
22 Feb 2017

This is officially the best place to live in the UK

And, surprise surprise, it isn’t London…

by Kayleigh Dray
22 Feb 2017

This Is Us star asks viewers to reach out to lost loved ones

“Tomorrow is not promised”

by Kayleigh Dray
22 Feb 2017

Inside the bar where men aren't allowed to approach women

"If a gentleman is lucky enough to be approached by a lady, he speaks to her as if he would speak to his mother”

by Sarah Biddlecombe
22 Feb 2017

Everything you need to know about growing your own vegetables

(Even if you don't have loads of space)

by Sarah Biddlecombe
21 Feb 2017

Calling all vino fans: are you ready for red wine ice cream?

Ice cream and red wine, together at last…

by Kayleigh Dray
21 Feb 2017

Letters penned 100 years apart show unchanging attitude to abortion

"I'm in the family way again, and I'm nearly crazy..."

by Sarah Biddlecombe
21 Feb 2017

Woman opens up about having her grandmother as her bridesmaid

“She’s my best friend”

by Kayleigh Dray
21 Feb 2017

Artist captures how mental illness feels with sketches of houses

“It belongs to our lives and we must not stigmatise it”

by Sarah Biddlecombe
21 Feb 2017

Pair cheese and wine like a pro with this incredible interactive map

Winchester Aged Gouda with a glass of Amarone della Valpolicella, anyone?

by Moya Crockett
21 Feb 2017