Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation

The great pie debate


When is a pie not a pie?

When it doesn't have a pastry lid.

Well, that's the official line anyway. Pies with a mash topping, instead of the traditional pastry don't technically have the right to be called 'pie'.

This leaves Shepherd's and Fish pies as pretenders to the title - a fact that's aggrieved one pub chain so much it's gone so far as to launch a 'pie-tition' in a bid to alter the official definition.

Puff pastry lid versus a sturdy butter pie crust - which is your favourite?

While Shepherd's and Fish pies may not officially deserve their names, some foodies feel that pies with a puff pastry top, rather than the full butter pastry encasing, are actually pies unworthy of the title.

Got beef with mash top pies? Despise floating puff pastry tops? Prefer it in a pot or on a plate?

vote for your favourite savoury pie and tell us your pie preferences in the comments box below...

By Anna Pollitt. Images: Rex Features



10 Holidays for the food obsessed


Top 25 reader holiday food photos


Stylist's 100 greatest recipes



Batch breakfast recipes to buy you more time in the morning

Never skip breakfast again. by Sejal Kapadia

01 Oct 2015

The world's most indulgent breakfast recipes

French toast roll-ups and double-stuffed Oreo pancakes by Amy Lewis

29 Sep 2015

How to make Eat Chic's legendary mini chocolate peanut butter cups

The ultimate sweet treat recipe

22 Sep 2015

Creamy smoothie bowls: recipes for the latest cult breakfast dish

Move over avocado. by Sejal Kapadia

16 Sep 2015

Recipes from Yotam Ottolenghi’s new cookbook

From courgette fritters to celeriac purée

11 Sep 2015

The Stylist Cake Off Competition Week 7

06 Sep 2015

21 glorious gin cocktails to make at home

Negronis, sours and slings. Oh my...

27 Aug 2015

How to bake the perfect loaf: Baking extraordinaire Cyril Blevanus

19 Aug 2015

The Stylist Cake Off competition Week Two: Bread

19 Aug 2015

Tips for sugar-free baking from Sophie Michell

19 Aug 2015