Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation
Top

The great pie debate

pie-hero.jpg

When is a pie not a pie?

When it doesn't have a pastry lid.

Well, that's the official line anyway. Pies with a mash topping, instead of the traditional pastry don't technically have the right to be called 'pie'.

This leaves Shepherd's and Fish pies as pretenders to the title - a fact that's aggrieved one pub chain so much it's gone so far as to launch a 'pie-tition' in a bid to alter the official definition.

Puff pastry lid versus a sturdy butter pie crust - which is your favourite?

While Shepherd's and Fish pies may not officially deserve their names, some foodies feel that pies with a puff pastry top, rather than the full butter pastry encasing, are actually pies unworthy of the title.

Got beef with mash top pies? Despise floating puff pastry tops? Prefer it in a pot or on a plate?

vote for your favourite savoury pie and tell us your pie preferences in the comments box below...

By Anna Pollitt. Images: Rex Features

Related

holidays.jpg

10 Holidays for the food obsessed

macs.jpg

Top 25 reader holiday food photos

herofood.jpg

Stylist's 100 greatest recipes

Latest...

Colin the Caterpillar has been given a cute Christmas makeover

We only just got over Halloween Colin – now Santa Colin is in town

by Kayleigh Dray
21 Sep 2017

Nutella's newest product sounds like all kinds of deliciousness

Nutella feasting can now happen any time, any place

by Megan Murray
20 Sep 2017

Cookie dough fans, your perfect store is coming to London

We HAVE to try the cookie dough clouds

by Megan Murray
19 Sep 2017

Unicorn cereal has arrived and breakfast will never be the same again

And here’s where you can buy it

by Susan Devaney
18 Sep 2017

These are our favourite gluten-free cakes, snacks and ingredients

From cakes to biscuits to beer and sausages

18 Sep 2017

Vegan Baileys will finally arrive in the UK this week

Here’s everything you need to know

by Megan Murray
18 Sep 2017

How to make your own sloe gin, in 3 easy steps

Just imagine the deliciousness...

by Magda Knight
15 Sep 2017

Aldi's wine advent calendar is the only Christmas countdown we need

It works out to be just £2 per bottle of vino - cheers to that!

by Megan Murray
15 Sep 2017

These beautiful doughnuts will completely blow your mind

Like glorious, edible works of art

by Charlotte Duck
14 Sep 2017

Aldi is releasing their biggest bottle of prosecco ever

All the bubbles

by Susan Devaney
14 Sep 2017