Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation

The great pie debate


When is a pie not a pie?

When it doesn't have a pastry lid.

Well, that's the official line anyway. Pies with a mash topping, instead of the traditional pastry don't technically have the right to be called 'pie'.

This leaves Shepherd's and Fish pies as pretenders to the title - a fact that's aggrieved one pub chain so much it's gone so far as to launch a 'pie-tition' in a bid to alter the official definition.

Puff pastry lid versus a sturdy butter pie crust - which is your favourite?

While Shepherd's and Fish pies may not officially deserve their names, some foodies feel that pies with a puff pastry top, rather than the full butter pastry encasing, are actually pies unworthy of the title.

Got beef with mash top pies? Despise floating puff pastry tops? Prefer it in a pot or on a plate?

vote for your favourite savoury pie and tell us your pie preferences in the comments box below...

By Anna Pollitt. Images: Rex Features



10 Holidays for the food obsessed


Top 25 reader holiday food photos


Stylist's 100 greatest recipes



20 ways to celebrate Thanksgiving

Hearty autumnal recipes from our friends across the pond

25 Nov 2015

10 Christmas recipes for a showstopping festive feast

10 showstopping recipes for a truly unforgettable festive feast

23 Nov 2015

Recipe: How to make Nigella’s Pumpkin bundt cake

Extracted from 'Simply Nigella: Feel Good Food'

23 Nov 2015

Forget sherry. These are the top wines to drink at Christmas

If Christmas was a wine, these would be it...

23 Nov 2015

Where to eat the best eggs in Britain

Weekend brunch lovers, ahoy

20 Nov 2015

Goodbye Cronuts. These are the hottest new baking creations

From biskies to ice-cream macarons

12 Nov 2015

World's first edible alcohol sweet shop comes to London

Your festive tipple, licked by Anna Pollitt

06 Nov 2015

Templates to create a Christmas gingerbread street

03 Nov 2015

The most filling and warming one-pot dishes

Minimal dishes, maximum flavour.

02 Nov 2015

How to cook the perfect poached egg

Top chefs decode the secret to poached egg perfection

30 Oct 2015