Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation

Rotherham abuse victim initially denied compensation because she gave “consent”

rotherham sex abuse compensation denied sammy woodhouse.jpg

One of the victims of the Rotherham abuse scandal has revealed she was initially denied a compensation payout, having being told that, at 14 years old, she had not been “manipulated or progressively lured” into a ‘relationship’ with a 24-year-old man.

Sammy Woodhouse, one of an estimated 1,400 children abused by a paedophile gang in Rotherham between 1997 and 2013 and systematically ignored by authorities, recently waived her right to anonymity in order to discuss the shocking sexual exploitation.

And while the ringleader, Arshid Hussain, was jailed for 35 years in 2016 for multiple offences against 15 girls including rape, abduction, making threats to kill and indecent assault, Woodhouse says her initial claim for compensation from the Criminal Injuries Compensation Authority (CICA) was turned down.

According to the BBC’s Inside Out Yorkshire and Lincolnshire, the response read: “I am not satisfied that your consent was falsely given as a result of being groomed by the offender.

“The evidence does not indicate that you were manipulated or progressively lured into a false relationship.”

Woodhouse told the BBC: “If an adult can privately think that it's a child's fault for being abused, beaten, raped, abducted, I think you're in the wrong job.”

three girls rotherham abuse scandal

Maxine Peake in BBC drama Three Girls, based on the Rotherham abuse scandal

Woodhouse appealed and was eventually awarded the maximum amount of compensation she qualified for.

Hussain’s brothers Basharat and Bannaras were jailed for 25 and 19 years respectively, while their uncle, Qurban Ali, was found guilty of conspiracy to rape and imprisoned for 10 years.

Earlier this year, BBC One’s drama Three Girls drew attention to the way the physical, sexual and emotional abuse and violence suffered by children over several years was consistently ignored by police, the council and social services – with vulnerable, underage girls being treated as if they were in genuine adult relationships with grown men or dismissed as ‘child prostitutes’.

In an interview with The Guardian in April, Woodhouse revealed how she was groomed, alienated from her friends and family, raped, subjected to almost daily violence and threatened with death. She fell pregnant twice, first having an abortion at the age of 14 then having a child when she was 15. She says the police knew her well, but didn’t see her as an underage girl being taken advantage of: “They always saw me as his equal. I was never treated as a victim. I was [seen as] part of his gang, his mistress.”

Read more: Everything you need to know about Three Girls and the real Sara Rowbotham

She added: “People say they didn’t know what grooming was back then. But if a police officer didn’t know it’s wrong for a 14- and a 24-year-old to be involved, then they were in the wrong occupation […]

“We were ‘slags’ and ‘little criminals’ [to them]. To this day, some people look at us like that.”

Devastating details were revealed in court, such as one woman who said abuse started when she was just 11, and she was passed around men as “payment” for the debts of her ‘boyfriend’ for years.

The extent of the problem was uncovered largely thanks to the dedication of Sara Rowbotham, a crisis intervention team coordinator working for a sexual health support service, who made it her mission to expose what she called a “major crisis where girls were being raped on an industrial scale.”

Woodhouse’s solicitor said of CICA’s initial decision: “I am utterly shocked by the notion that decision-makers in a government organisation can consider that 14 or 15-year-old girls can consent to sex with adults.

“They decided she must have consented when it’s just not legally possible.”

A Freedom of Information request by the BBC revealed nearly 700 child victims of sexual abuse, including grooming, have been refused payments.

A CICA spokesperson said the compensation body was reviewing its guidance by consulting with organisations such as Barnardo’s and Victim Support to make sure the new advice would be “as robust as it possibly can be”.

Image: BBC One / Rex Features



Anonymous voting for domestic abuse survivors


Three women share their inspiring stories of escaping domestic abuse


Lucy Mangan: “Apathy is domestic violence's biggest ally”


Students told to submit dresses for approval ahead of school dance

“These are the roots of rape culture, frankly”

by Amy Swales
19 Sep 2017

This is why hardly any men are taking shared parental leave in the UK

Women are still doing the lion’s share of childcare, while men go out to work

by Moya Crockett
19 Sep 2017

Woman finally approaches rush-hour crush, ends up marrying him

She waited a year for him to notice her – and then she took matters into her own hands

by Kayleigh Dray
19 Sep 2017

Dreaming of buying a French Bulldog? Read this first

The secret cost of that Instagram-perfect pup

by Amy Swales
19 Sep 2017

Cookie dough fans, your perfect store is coming to London

We HAVE to try the cookie dough clouds

by Megan Murray
19 Sep 2017

Hilarious Instagram account fulfills all our eavesdropping dreams

‘Overheard London’ documents the capital's weirdest conversations – ever

by Kayleigh Dray
19 Sep 2017

This guy has a creative way of helping his girlfriend’s depression

His post has stolen the hearts of the online community

by Susan Devaney
19 Sep 2017

Love Actually is getting a musical makeover for Christmas

It involves a live orchestra

by Amy Swales
19 Sep 2017

A Hillary Clinton-inspired Nasty Women exhibition has arrived

Because if the US election taught us anything, it’s that misogyny is still rife

by Susan Devaney
19 Sep 2017

Uber forced to apologise for sexist ‘Wife Appreciation Day’ message

“Thank you, Uber, for defining gender roles.”

by Moya Crockett
19 Sep 2017