Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation
Top

Are they lying? The surprising new ways to tell if someone is being dishonest

ThinkstockPhotos-488052914.jpg

Looking someone in the eye and lying to them is apparently much easier than Hollywood films and politicians have led us to believe.

Researchers who watched hundreds of hours of video footage of lying criminals in high-profile court cases have found that fibbers share a surprising selection of common tells.

A team at the University of Michigan discovered that far from averting their gaze, people actually make more eye contact when they lie.

Being dishonest also makes people scowl and use their hands more.

The study found people share these traits when lying:

  • Move their hands a lot
  • Scowl or grimace their whole face
  • Use fillers such as "um," "uh" and "ah" 
  • Try to sound more certain
  • Look their questioners in the eye more often than those telling the truth

"People are poor lie detectors," says study leader Dr Rada Mihalcea, professor of computer science and engineering. "This isn't the kind of task we're naturally good at."

"There are clues that humans give naturally when they are being deceptive, but we're not paying close enough attention to pick them up," she adds. "We're not counting how many times a person says 'I' or looks up. We're focusing on a higher level of communication."

couple

"I adore your new purple shirt," says Emma, staring deep into Mark's eyes

The team examined footage from witnesses and defendants in 120 court cases and based their honesty on the outcomes of the trials. They have now developed the first lie-detecting software that examines words and gestures and doesn't require hooking people up to machines.

In tests, the software correctly identified when people were lying in 75% of cases, while humans can generally catch out lies only 50% of the time.

While previous findings have indicated that people tend to look away when they lie, Dr Mihalcea says it's difficult to motivate study participants to truly lie in a laboratory setting. She says her team's research is based on "real world" dishonesty where there is true motivation to deceive.

Images: Thinkstock

Related

gingerbread.jpg

Winning Christmas? The life-size gingerbread house

ThinkstockPhotos-483800191.jpg

Behold the UK's most cringeworthy office jargon

christmas_cracker_lead_v1.jpg

The Stylist Christmas cracker roadtest

book-review-a-brief-history-of-seven-killings-marlon-james-ali-smith-how-to-be-both.jpg

Book wars: A Brief History of Seven Killings versus How to be Both

fashion_style_faux_fur_high_street_4.jpg

Faking it: wrap up with this season’s fierce faux furs

exclamation mark.jpg

This one texting habit is a sign of insincerity, according to science

ThinkstockPhotos-475951130.jpg

These are the most popular beauty products of 2015

ariel-make-up.jpg

Ariel will have blonde hair in The Little Mermaid remake

serial.png

Serial is back! Listen to season two right here

More

“Why I opted out of reconstruction after my double mastectomy”

Breast cancer survivor Jeanne Paul says many don’t understand her choice

by Amy Swales
21 Aug 2017

Carpool Karaoke gets a Game of Thrones makeover

The Starks are in town

by Amy Swales
21 Aug 2017

How the solar eclipse could completely transform your life

An astrologer tells us how to tap into the ‘magical powers’ of tonight’s eclipse

by Kayleigh Dray
21 Aug 2017

Lidl is selling £3.33 bottles of prosecco – but there’s a catch

Bring on the bubbles

by Megan Murray
21 Aug 2017

Singer stops concert to expertly shame man for sexual assault

“It is not your f**king body and you do not f**king grab at someone!”

by Sarah Biddlecombe
21 Aug 2017

Why that Game of Thrones infertility storyline is so very important

This article contains spoilers, obviously

by Kayleigh Dray
21 Aug 2017

“I’m child-free, not childless – why the difference matters”

One writer on how our language shames women who choose not to procreate

21 Aug 2017

High school boys support female students against sexist dress code

And this is how it’s done

by Megan Murray
21 Aug 2017

Why people are posting cat photos in response to the Barcelona attacks

There’s a reason behind the influx of felines online

by Kayleigh Dray
21 Aug 2017

The deadly secret hidden within that creepy Game of Thrones hug

Spoilers are coming…

by Kayleigh Dray
18 Aug 2017