Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation

Study asks men and women what’s worse; emotional or sexual infidelity?


What’s worse; discovering that a partner has been having sex with somebody else, or knowing that they’ve had an ‘emotional affair’?

Naturally, neither choice is great if you’re one for monogamy, but a new study has dipped its toe into the complex waters of cheating and infidelity, to try draw some conclusions about why - and how - people in relationships cheat.

Led by  Dr David Frederick, a psychology professor at Chapman University, California, the research team asked over 63,000 gay, lesbian, bisexual and heterosexual people the above question, and the results may surprise you.

Man and woman break up

Here’s how the researchers put it to the participants:

Which scenario would upset you more: a partner having sex with someone else (but not falling in love with them) or a partner falling in love with someone else (but not having sex with them)?

As Frederick hypothesised, 65% of heterosexual women said they’d more upset by their partner’s emotional cheating, compared with the physical.

Bisexual men and women, plus gay men and women all agreed, with the majority of participants in all four of these categories voting in very similar ways when asked how they felt about the hypothetical infidelity.

The only group that differed was heterosexual men.

54% of straight men agreed that they’d be more upset if their partner had sex with somebody else, compared with if they’d had an emotional affair without any sexual infidelity at all.

Man at laptop

The reason for this, surmises Frederick, is all down to evolutionary principles.

“One hypothesis derived from evolutionary perspectives is that men are more upset than women by sexual infidelity and women are more upset than men by emotional infidelity,” he writes. “The proposed explanation is that men, in contrast to women, face the risk of unwittingly investing in genetically unrelated offspring.”

That sexual jealousy is more prominent among heterosexual men compared with gay or bisexual men goes some way to backing Frederick’s theory even further.

In evolutionary terms, heterosexual men are 'programmed' to seek paternal security. Where there’s less chance of pregnancy, there’s less likely to the same level of sexual jealousy.



girls series 6 spoilers.jpg

Girls spoiler: new photos of Lena Dunham expose major plot twist

runaway bride wedding.jpg

Women explain why they never want to get married


Why men don’t message first on Tinder, according to science

alice brine comedian.jpeg

Comedian's argument about victim blaming goes viral on Facebook

the break up movie still.jpg

Experts reveal word you should avoid when fighting with your partner

buffy the vampire slayer life lessons.jpg

From feminism to self-belief: life lessons Buffy Summers taught us

The 3rd Annual March for Choice, Dublin, Ireland - 27 Sep 2014 - abortion protest.jpg

#Repealthe8th: woman shares powerful teen abortion story

Mila Kunis

Mila Kunis unveils bargain wedding ring: "we bought it on Etsy"


Everyone is loving Victoria Beckham’s high fashion Pokémon characters


This Princess Bride revelation will make you see the film in a new way

It’s been 30 years since it hit the big screen

by Susan Devaney
17 Oct 2017

What is perspecticide and could it be happening in your relationship?

This form of coercive control is incredibly damaging

by Megan Murray
16 Oct 2017

5 of the best indulgent baking books

Take a moment for yourself and make yourself some sweet baked goodness

16 Oct 2017

Here’s why your NHS doctor may ask you about your sexuality

The new directive will start in 2019

by Susan Devaney
16 Oct 2017

UK police investigate 5 sexual assault claims against Harvey Weinstein

Including one brought by Hollyoaks actress Lysette Anthony

by Moya Crockett
16 Oct 2017

#WomenBoycottTwitter: Here’s why women are refusing to tweet today

How will women going silent help their cause?

by Kayleigh Dray
13 Oct 2017

Lucy Mangan on why it's OK to feel vulnerable in these dark times

It’s reasonable to feel shaken by horrific news stories – we just mustn’t let them change us permanently

by Lucy Mangan
12 Oct 2017

Here’s what to do if your work space is driving you to distraction

Do you function better amid the chatter of colleagues?

12 Oct 2017