Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation
Top

Why IS Louise Minchin still in the 'inferior' seat? BBC embroiled in sexism row over sofa seniority

dwlm.jpg

You don't have to be a TV presenter for Louise Minchin's situation at BBC Breakfast to strike a chord.

The longserving newscaster and presenter is caught up in a depressingly familiar sexism debate over a lesser-experienced male colleague being handed a position that should rightfully be hers.

After waving off senior co-presenter Bill Turnbull in September, Minchin's place on the show remains the same, while her new, less experienced colleague Dan Walker has slid into Turnbull's coveted lead position on the lefthand side of our screens.

Viewer Adele Clarke first brought the sly inequity to national attention in a letter of complaint to the Radio Times.

Annoyed to see "new boy" Walker in Turnbull's spot when he started earlier this month, she asked: "How long will it take the BBC (and most other news stations) to catch up with the rest of us in the 21st century? Be brave - try seating a woman on the left and see how the world will keep turning".

BBC Breakfast in 2000 with Jeremy Bowen And Sophie Raworth

Starting as it meant to go on: BBC Breakfast in 2000 with Jeremy Bowen And Sophie Raworth

Given that we're talking about settee spots on a TV show, it's easy - or more convenient - to dismiss the row as petty or trivial, but imagine it in the context of your own workplace.

If you were next in line for the prime desk in the office, a cushty work trip, that CV-enhancing course - or worse; a pay rise or promotion - and it was given to a new staff member with far less experience, you'd rightfully feel rattled, whatever that person's gender. 

Whether viewers realise it or not, Walker, 38, has been placed in what the industry deems a prime spot - seated directly next to guests and in the centre of the screen during interviews. Our left-to-right reading Western minds subconsciously place importance on the first things our eyes land on and that's why it's a plum position for presenters. Why wasn't Minchin, 47, who's been in what's considered a junior seat for 10 years, automatically moved up to that position?

The BBC has insisted: "There is no seniority in terms of who sits where." But it's a line that's difficult to swallow when the majority of news and current affairs we watch on TV sit their male presenters on the left and the experienced Turnbull occupied that very spot for 15 years.

"There is no seniority in terms of who sits where on the BBC Breakfast sofa. It’s all about judging which is the best camera angle for the presenters." - A BBC spokesman

Maybe snagging the prime place didn't even cross Minchin's mind. Perhaps she's left-handed and is clinging onto the junior side of the sofa for convenience. 

It could be that her pay packet far exceeds Walker's in reflection of her seniority and experience. However, viewers can't see wages onscreen. 

Body language expert Judi James says that by handing the "camera left" position to a new male co-presenter, the BBC is insidiously damaging how society views women.

"This absolutely reinforces the idea that women are inferior," James told RadioTimes.com. "It's really one of the hugest bastions of sexism that in any double act that you get on television where there's a man and a woman it's pretty much always seen that the guy is the dominant alpha and that it's reflected in where they sit."

Miriam O’Reilly, who won an ageism case against the BBC after she was dropped from Countryfile, told The Guardian that from her experience in newsrooms, men are seen as having "gravitas" onscreen while women are viewed as "his bit of fluff on the side."

"It’s just deep-rooted misogyny in newsrooms where editors think a man somehow has more authority ... And of course the people who make these decisions tend to be men themselves."

Before he even appeared on the show, Walker's stage was being set by reports hailing him as Turnbull's "replacement". Why, given Minchin's stature, did the Beeb choose not to position her as the replacement - aka lead presenter and top dog - and present Walker as the new junior?

Whether or not Minchin did complain to producers, as suggested by The Telegraph, or is absolutely fine with a new junior colleague taking Turnbull's spot, the Beeb's vague comment on "judging the best camera angles" seems a weak and evasive explanation. 

Keeping Minchin static and suggesting to viewers that Walker is the "new" Turnbull simply because they are both men is sexism hiding in plain sight.

At the very least, sofa-gate has opened up debate:

Turnbull and Walker have joked about the sexism row on Twitter - Minchin has yet to respond:

Related

womenhero2.jpg

Enough 'girls' and 'ladies' - we're women

Kim-k.jpg

Why our clique called feminism won't accept Kim K's naked selfie

emojis 2.jpg

Pink sweaters, girls dancing in bunny ears: are emoji sexist?

bridemaids.jpg

The alarming reason bridesmaids traditionally wear matching dresses

make-up-by-alaha.jpg

Beauty blogger applies a full face of make-up during labour

309_tablet_scoop2_pizza_lead_v1.jpg

Eat the best pizza (wherever you are)

opener_rt.jpg

How to find the right red lipstick for your skin tone

iStock_000059737178_Medium.jpg

Middle class pick up lines take the internet by storm

rexfeatures_5593469fr.jpg

Does Adele have the best stage chat of them all?

Comments

More

Serena Williams had the best response for reporter who criticised her

"Are you serious?"

by Sarah Biddlecombe
20 Jan 2017

Married at First Sight’s Caroline reveals truth about marriage to Adam

Steel yourselves, romantics

by Kayleigh Dray
20 Jan 2017

Listen to A-listers narrate the history of Planned Parenthood

“No woman can call herself free who does not own and control her body”

by Sarah Biddlecombe
19 Jan 2017

Wife Swap set to return with one-off Brexit special

What happens when a Remain voter finds herself living in a family of Brexit fans?

by Kayleigh Dray
19 Jan 2017

The 2017 Feminist Calendar: celebrate the sisterhood all year round

The future is female

by The Stylist web team
19 Jan 2017

Unicorn lattes are the new brunch trend taking over your Instagram

These healing concoctions are almost too pretty to drink

by Kayleigh Dray
19 Jan 2017

Will & Grace is officially coming back to TV and we can’t wait

NBC has ordered 10 new episodes of the iconic show to air later this year.

by Moya Crockett
19 Jan 2017

Men refuse to apply for jobs that use “feminine” words

They don't want to be "sympathetic" or "caring"

by Sarah Biddlecombe
19 Jan 2017

This new DIY divorce app vows to help you to ‘consciously uncouple’

Because there really is an app for everything nowadays

by Kayleigh Dray
18 Jan 2017

Rachel Court wants employers to watch for these abuse warning signs

A woman who survived being shot by her husband has shared a letter from her old boss, revealing the extent to which her partner controlled her life for years

by Kayleigh Dray
18 Jan 2017