Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation
Top

Woman battles for right to use her deceased daughter's eggs to conceive a child

iStock_000083181011_Medium.jpg

A 60-year-old woman is appealing a court ruling that states she cannot use her deceased daughter's eggs to conceive a child.

The woman, who is from the UK, wants to take her daughter's frozen eggs to a clinic in the US to be inseminated with donor sperm. Her daughter, who is her only child, is said to have approved of the plan before she died five years ago aged 28 from bowel cancer.

However, the UK's fertility regulator, the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA), denied her request to release her daughter's eggs from storage in 2014 because she had not given full written consent.

syringe

The 60-year-old woman wants to uphold her daughter's wish to have a child

The woman appealed this decision in 2015 and said during High Court proceedings in June last year that her daughter had been desperate to have children. The court head that she had asked her mother to "carry [her] babies" and would have been "devastated" to know her eggs would not be used.

But a judge upheld the ruling, saying that although the daughter had consented for her eggs to be frozen for use after her death, she had not left the "required consent" for her mother to use them.

The mother appealed this decision again in February of this year, with her lawyers telling the court there was "clear evidence" her daughter wanted her mother to use her eggs after her death. After healing the appeal, Lord Justice Treacy said there was "an arguable case with a real prospect of success".

The mother continued her appeal at the Court of Appeal yesterday, presenting her case to three judges including president of the High Court's family division, Sir James Munby. A decision has not yet been announced.

The case is reminiscent of a woman in the US who last month spoke out on her decision to use sperm from her deceased husband's body to conceive a child.

If the mother wins the appeal she will become the first ever woman to become pregnant with a child conceived using the egg of a deceased daughter.

Related

facebook receipt random act kindness waitress grieving customer leaves tip message.jpg

Grieving customer pens sweet message to waitress

woman.jpg

The heartwarming foreign words that have no direct English translation

iStock_000073919951_Medium.jpg

Shocking extent of misogyny on social media revealed in new study

winnie1.jpg

Winnie-the-Pooh visits Buckingham Palace

beyonce power pose.jpg

Want to do well at work? You’d better learn to stand like a man

iStock_000071674951_Large.jpg

Get ready: London's giant gin hotel will open next month

kenzo.jpg

The latest H&M designer collaboration is here, and we're excited

65889071_thumbnail.jpg

One in five UK couples are at risk of break-up, report finds

iStock_000026720078_Large.jpg

Why one woman chose to extract sperm after her husband's sudden death

Comments

More

First Dates’ Raymond taught us an important lesson about loneliness

by Kayleigh Dray
27 Apr 2017

These cheesy, cheesy recipes will give you life

Get a load of this fromagerie

by Jasmine Andersson
27 Apr 2017

This Commuter Barbie video is the most relatable thing we’ve ever seen

“Commuter Barbie has a seat at the table – and on the train!”

by Sarah Biddlecombe
27 Apr 2017

Woman thrown out of her gym for wearing a sports bra

Her workout clothes were deemed inappropriate by staff

by Hayley Spencer
27 Apr 2017

Black goth ice cream is here to save 2017

Wednesday Addams, eat your heart out

by Sarah Biddlecombe
27 Apr 2017

This is why we won't be getting a Bridesmaids sequel

Some movies really are best left alone.

27 Apr 2017

These are the 15 best-paying careers if you want to travel the world

Time for a change?

by Moya Crockett
27 Apr 2017

Scientists create artificial womb that could save premature babies

The new research is groundbreaking

by Sarah Biddlecombe
26 Apr 2017

First Dates viewers in tears over cancer survivor’s “perfect ending”

Sarah, who had her leg amputated at 16, just wanted someone to carry her into the sea

by Kayleigh Dray
26 Apr 2017

11 craft beers to make you feel summery whatever the weather

Bottles and cans to lift your spirits (beers)

by Amy Swales
26 Apr 2017