Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation

Author Hilary Mantel takes aim at compassionate Diana ‘myth’


Wolf Hall author Hilary Mantel has questioned the reverence of what she terms the Princess Diana “myth”, in a caustic article ahead of the 20th anniversary of the royal’s sudden death in a car crash this week.

In a combative essay for the Guardian, the novelist breaks rank with the common perception of Diana as “the people’s princess” by challenging the true extent of her kindness and integrity – both virtues associated with the late royal by the media and the public at large.

Piecing together interviews and anecdotal evidence, Mantel argues that Diana is not the unambiguous hero that we want her to be.

As an example, she cites the recent Channel 4 documentary, Diana In Her Own Words. This touts the royal family’s most notorious member as being “candid” and “uninhibited”, Mantel writes.

Instead, Mantel claims that the footage shows her to be “squirming, twitching, avoiding the camera’s eye”.

“She describes herself hopefully as ‘a rebel’ on the grounds that she liked to do the opposite of everyone else,” writes Mantel. “You want to veil the lens and explain: that is reaction, not rebellion. Throwing a tantrum when thwarted doesn’t make you a free spirit. Rolling your eyes and shrugging doesn’t prove you are brave. And because people say ‘trust me’, it doesn’t means they’ll keep your secrets.”

Hilary Mantel has attacked what she calls the Princess Diana "myth"

Author Hilary Mantel has attacked what she calls the Princess Diana "myth"

Mantel also calls Diana’s legendary selflessness into question.

“By her own account, Diana was not clever,” she writes. “Nor was she especially good, in the sense of having a dependable inclination to virtue; she was quixotically loving, not steadily charitable: mutable, not dependable: given to infatuation, prey to impulse. This is not a criticism. 

“… When people described Diana as a ‘fairytale princess’, were they thinking of the cleaned-up versions? Fairytales are not about gauzy frocks and ego gratification.”

Read more: The baffling and bizarre rules of royal etiquette

Although Mantel admits “to her credit, she [Diana] had begun to work actively to lessen the amount of pain in the world” in her charity work after separating from Prince Charles in early 1990s, she is cynical about the “legend” that these acts have since given rise to.

“She visited the sick, and stopped just short of claiming the healing touch that custom bestows on the divinely anointed; had she become queen, she would surely have gone about raising the dead,” Mantel says. “Legend insists she showed the world that it was safe to shake hands with a person with Aids.

“Even in the unenlightened days of 1987, only the bigoted and ignorant thought casual contact would infect them, but any gesture from Diana was worth years of public education and millions in funding.”

Diana: not the unambiguous hero we understand her to be, says Mantel

Diana: not the unambiguous hero we understand her to be, says Mantel

Mantel – a two times Booker Prize winner – is also critical of other members of the royal family, in the far-reaching opinion piece.

She accuses the queen of lacking in warmth or love; “a queen who, even at Diana’s death, was reluctant to descend from the cold north”.

At the time of marrying Diana, Prince Charles, she says, affected an “attitude of anxious perplexity” which masked his “obtuseness” about what their marriage meant to her.

Read more: How Princess Diana nailed every dress code

Mantel claims Diana became a focus for public affection simply because there were few other options in the royal family:  “A soft-eyed, fertile blond, she represented conjugal and maternal love, and what other source did we have?”

She says that in the years since Diana’s death in Paris in 1997, we have created a myth around who she was that is forever shifting – and is also palpably not realistic to the person she was.

The historical fiction author previously sparked controversy by describing Kate Middleton, the Duchess of Cambridge as a “shop-window mannequin” whose only purpose was to breed.

“She seems to have been selected for her role of princess because she was irreproachable: as painfully thin as anyone could wish, without quirks, without oddities, without the risk of the emergence of character,” Mantel said, during a lecture at the British Museum in 2013.

“She appears precision-made, machine-made: so different from Diana, whose human awkwardness and emotional incontinence showed in her every gesture.”

Images: Rex 


princess diana prince william duke of cambridge prince harry 2.jpg

Princes William and Harry reveal the last words they spoke to Diana

Arundhati Roy use.jpg

Arundhati Roy leads Man Booker longlist, 20 years after first triumph


Prince Harry emotionally criticizes the paparazzi over Diana’s death


The best A-list Instagrams from the week so far

From Dakota Johnson’s hidden talent to David Beckham’s sweet moment

by Nicola Colyer
26 Sep 2017

Diane Abbott calls for end to abuse of BBC’s Laura Kuenssberg

“Why – just because she is a woman journalist – does she get that level of abuse?”

by Moya Crockett
26 Sep 2017

The important life lessons that Barack Obama taught his daughters

Guaranteed to leave you feeling more than a bit emotional...

by Kayleigh Dray
26 Sep 2017

“We should all be angry that Laura Kuenssberg needs a bodyguard”

The BBC's political editor needs protection because of misogyny, pure and simple

by Ellie Mae O’Hagan
25 Sep 2017

Piers Morgan's comments about Meghan Markle have riled up the internet

A heavy dose of sexism with your morning telly

by Kayleigh Dray
25 Sep 2017

Julia Stiles talks women in Hollywood and her controversial baby name

Stylist.co.uk chats with the Riviera star

by Harriet Hall
25 Sep 2017

Chrissy Teigen’s reason for never divorcing John Legend is too good

Just when we thought we couldn’t love her more

by Susan Devaney
25 Sep 2017

NASA just paid tribute to Hidden Figures' Katherine Johnson

This is long overdue

by Susan Devaney
25 Sep 2017

Ellen DeGeneres has officially banned Donald Trump from her TV show

Her powerful statement sums up everything that’s wrong with the president

by Kayleigh Dray
25 Sep 2017

Jessica Ennis-Hill unveils baby girl’s incredibly trendy name

The gold medallist announced the news via an intimate Instagram photo

by Kayleigh Dray
25 Sep 2017