Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation
Top

Court rejects appeal and throws out Kesha's Dr Luke ‘hate crime’ rape claims

kesha ke$ha legal case dr luke.jpg

A New York judge has dismissed Kesha's bid to get out of her contract with Sony Music.

The singer’s legal team lodged an appeal after her request for a preliminary injunction to release her from her contract with Sony's Kemosabe Records was turned down in February.

Kemosabe Records is run by Dr Luke (real name Lukasz Gottwald), the music producer she alleges raped and sexually and emotionally abused her over a 10-year period.

But Manhattan state Supreme Court Justice Shirley Werner Kornreich said many of Kesha’s claims did not meet the required legal standards; while her legal team said Gottwald’s alleged behaviour constituted a hate crime, the judge disagreed, ruling, “There are no facts to support Gottwald’s animus toward women.

“Gottwald is alleged to have made offensive remarks about Kesha’s weight, appearance, and talent, not about women in general […] Every rape is not a gender-motivated hate crime.”

The judge also said the singer’s human rights were not being violated by keeping the contract in place as Sony had said she could record with Kemosabe without Gottwald’s involvement, a situation her legal team had previously likened to “slavery”.

Furthermore, the ruling said many of the incidents Kesha, 29, described had allegedly taken place too long ago to be considered, and that her team had “failed to plead that any of the alleged discrimination occurred in New York State or City” – meaning the court had no jurisdiction.

With regards to the emotional abuse Kesha has alleged against Gottwald, which she says resulted in bulimia, depression, stress and panic attacks, the ruling stated that “insults about her value as an artist, her looks and her weight are insufficient to constitute extreme, outrageous conduct intolerable in a civilised society.”

Kesha filed a lawsuit against Gottwald in 2014 alleging, among other things, sexual assault and battery, sexual harassment, gender violence and emotional distress.

Earlier this week, she posted a message on Instagram claiming she’d been offered “freedom” from her contract in return for publicly retracting her claims. The sexual assault case will be heard in 2017, while related lawsuits in California and Tennessee are ongoing.

Related

kesha new york supreme state court appeal judge dr luke.jpg

Kesha says she was offered “freedom” if she retracted rape claims

rexfeatures_5528400dc.jpg

Lady Gaga on the lasting emotional pain of sexual assault

rexfeatures_5600075am.jpg

Lady Gaga on why female artists are wary of #FreeKe$ha

rexfeatures_5593469fs.jpg

Adele shares her support for Kesha in emotional Brits speech

rexfeatures_3456563a.jpg

European train operator launches women-only train carriages

GettyImages-512943218.jpg

Watch Lady Gaga's powerful Oscars performance bring A-list to tears

Jaime King

Lady Gaga inspires Jaime King to speak out on childhood sexual abuse

rachel mcadams oscars 2016.jpg

2016 Oscars red carpet arrivals: all the A-list fashion

Melanie Gleason.jpg

Meet the nomad lawyer who travels America fighting for social justice

More

Margot Robbie writes stirring open letter to Hollywood

by Nicola Colyer
19 Oct 2017

Gabrielle Union shares a powerful message about rape and harassment

The star says she’ll “keep talking out” for survivors like herself

by Susan Devaney
19 Oct 2017

Why the singer has opened up about her mental health

The singer says it was “really, really bad” during her time with the band

by Susan Devaney
19 Oct 2017

The best A-list Instagrams from the week so far

From Madonna’s touching tribute to a Cruel Intentions reunion

by Nicola Colyer
19 Oct 2017

Anna Faris understands why people were obsessed with her relationship

She and Chris Pratt were often hailed as #relationshipgoals

by Amy Swales
19 Oct 2017

Cher is starring in the Mamma Mia! sequel and we can’t wait for 2018

Can you hear the drums, Fernando?

by Susan Devaney
18 Oct 2017

Game of Thrones’ Lena Headey shares shocking sexual harassment story

“I got in my car and cried”

by Susan Devaney
18 Oct 2017

Jennifer Lawrence was forced into a naked line-up by a producer

In the name of weight-loss “inspiration”

by Amy Swales
17 Oct 2017

Abigail Breslin’s photo reveals how domestic abuse can stay with you

The actor has opened up about the realities of living with PTSD

17 Oct 2017

“Why Liar is proof that TV's depiction of rape is damaging to women”

The proliferation of rape in TV and film is a real problem for the representation of women

by Harriet Hall
17 Oct 2017