Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation
Top

'My four-year-old daughter only wears pink and wants to be a princess. What have I done wrong?'

princess-in-pink.jpg

Ask A Feminist is Stylist.co.uk's weekly column answering your questions on feminism, sexism and womanhood in a real-life, 21st Century context. Send your dilemmas to stories@stylist.co.uk and we'll get one of our brilliant panel of feminists to cast a discerning eye on the issue at hand. 

This week's question:

"My daughter is four. She only likes to wear pink and says she wants to be a princess when she grows up. I’m aghast. What have I done wrong?"

Katharine Busby

Feminist Katharine Busby says:

Ah, lovely pink. Who’d have thought a colour could cause such commotion?

Pink’s bad press is tied in with the fact that, these days, girls and boys are marketed to differently.

For me, a child of the 70s and 80s, who remembers that golden era of primary-coloured Lego, the Yellow Teapot and everyone, regardless of gender, wearing brown trousers, this is a new and alien concept.

But for a child born in the past 15 years or so, it’s a fact of life.

Pink stuff, in the eyes of the toy and book manufacturers, is for girls, dull colours are for boys. Case in point, Usborne’s activity books – girls apparently like activities that involve flowers and hearts, boys like making paper aeroplanes, robots and dinosaurs.

Sigh.

Yes, polarising children into stereotypes is commonplace among marketing and sales teams.

But we can’t just blame the people making this stuff. Although you’re not buying into the pink thing, there are plenty of parents who are. Gender stereotyping is culturally ingrained to the degree that there are still plenty of mums telling their sons they can’t wear pink (ironic really, given that a 2012 study discovered men who sport pink shirts typically earn more than their non-pink-wearing colleagues).

Girls in pink

Tiaras, wands - and gender stereotyping

You’re not alone in your feelings, however.

There is a wave of campaigns hoping to change the way retailers and toy manufacturers appeal to the two genders – Let Toys Be Toys and Let Books Be Books are both well supported projects, while the more angrily named Pink Stinks targets "products, media and marketing that… are limiting roles to young girls", their website explains. 

And these campaigns are having some success – when the most famous toy shop in the country, Hamley’s, dropped its "boys" and "girls" floors in 2011, it was hailed as a step forward.

You haven’t done anything wrong.

But right now your daughter is four. She likes pink (and okay, currently she likes it exclusively). She has probably heard more stories about princesses living happily ever after than she has ones about really successful lawyers living happily ever after.

At four, you don’t know much about career options, so being a princess seems quite a good one. Your daughter isn’t wrong either, or an anti-feminist, she just has unrealistic career hopes; as does my daughter, who wishes to be a dinosaur. Let them find out about the realities of the working world later down the line.

Push your point too much to a four-year-old and you risk creating a drama out of a phase.

So long as you keep offering up alternatives to the endless princess-y production line, your daughter is likely to branch out soon anyway. In Pink Brain Blue Brain, Professor Lise Eliot writes about a Swedish study, which found that, "Girls begin opening up around four or five, experimenting more with toy vehicles, sports games, and other blue- and black-coloured toys that they avoided a year or two earlier". 

So, don’t chuck out that pick-up truck you enthusiastically bought her just yet.

Children are full of surprises.

What do you think? Does it matter if young girls tend towards pink and princesses? Should parents work to combat gender stereotyping, or just accept it as a fact of growing up? We want to hear your thoughts in the comments section, below

Related

rexfeatures_2357273a.jpg

Publisher Ladybird drops gender-specific children's book titles

rexfeatures-1851097a.jpg

Critics slam 'Barbie' holiday for little girls

mean-girls-where-now.jpg

'Is it acceptable to bitch about other women?'

ross-poldark-aiden-turner-in-poldark.jpg

'Is it OK to objectify Poldark?'

bey.jpg

'Who has the right to talk about feminism?'

anofficerandagentleman-590x350.jpg

'I like to feel protected by my husband. Am I a hypocrite feminist?'

Comments

More

Ched Evans wants you to drink less to avoid being raped

Ask a Feminist despairs at the latest comments from footballer, Ched Evans.

by Rhiannon Lucy Cosslett
18 May 2017

Women of France, rejoice! A man has been elected President

by The Stylist web team
08 May 2017

“Why it’s time we challenged the idea of the feminine beauty ideal”

The war on make-up and 'natural' looks must end

by The Stylist web team
04 May 2017

“No more excuses: Why it’s time men joined the feminist fight”

We need to stop seeing gender equality as just a women’s issue

by The Stylist web team
11 Apr 2017

“The Daily Mail is proof that no woman can escape objectification”

It doesn’t matter if you're the Prime Minister: sexism will continue to plague you.

by Moya Crockett
28 Mar 2017

How to win every sexist argument: an 11-point guide

“What’s wrong with catcalling? Can’t you take a compliment?”

by Laura Bates
08 Mar 2017

Harriet Harman: “Don't turn back the clock on gender equality”

“For years we've battled against male chauvinist attitudes”

by The Stylist web team
06 Mar 2017

“The phoney outrage at Emma Watson’s breasts is laughably transparent"

“Emma Watson’s breasts don’t make her empowered– or a hypocrite”

by Harriet Hall
03 Mar 2017

“Access to civil partnership is a feminist issue”

Katie Russell explains why the institution of marriage does not serve women

by The Stylist web team
22 Feb 2017

“Disgusting and overrated: we should all be the women Trump despises”

by Anna Brech
27 Jan 2017