Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation
Top

Hilary Mantel: I stand by 'plastic' Kate comments

hilkmhero.jpg
kmhero.jpg

Award-winning author Hilary Mantel has spoken out about her famously divisive critique on Kate Middleton, saying she stands by the comments she made about the Duchess.

In her 2013 essay Royal Bodies, Mantel discussed the royal family's place in society and more specifically, the pervading scrutiny and treatment of its women.

In it, she described the Duchess of Cambridge as a "shop window mannequin" with a "plastic smile" and "without the risk of the emergence of character."

While some praised the Booker Prize-winning author's lecture as an eloquent feminist insight into the media's portrayal of female royals, others honed in on some of the work's juiciest soundbites and branded her comments a personal attack on the Duchess.

The Prime Minister even spoke out against the essay, defending Middleton as "bright and engaging" and labelling Mantel's remarks as "misguided".

Speaking to Sky News, Mantel, 61, said such criticism is indicative of an increasingly "intolerant" Britain.

"What the fuss last year made me think was how narrow and how intolerant as a nation we have become because even if I had said about Kate the things I was alleged to have said, that was my perfect right," she said.

"There was no occasion to jump on me and revile me," the Wolf Hall author added. "I would say it all over again and I stand by what I said."

At the time The Daily Mail described her comments as "an astonishing and venomous attack" and the Guardian said it was a "damning" take, while The Independent published a supportive review of the piece.

The Daily Beast also called the work "a tender and sympathetic piece of writing, filled with compassion for royal women trapped in their gilded cages."

Mantel has previously declared that the essay was "actually supportive of the Royal Family".

"When I used those words about the Duchess of Cambridge, I was describing the perception of her which has been set up in the tabloid press," she added.

Related

emma-watson.jpg

Number of women on rich list up 50% in past decade

helenahero.jpg

BAFTA 2014 goes gothic: Red Carpet Arrivals

kate-M.jpg

Official portrait of Kate Middleton unveiled

katemid.jpg

The many faces of Kate Middleton

rexfeatures_1921691a.jpg

Hilary Mantel makes history with Man Booker win

kate-hero.jpg

Kate Middleton's best outfits from the Royal tour

Comments

More

Paloma Faith pens emotional letter to NHS following birth of her baby

She made her feelings about the NHS very clear following her emergency C-section

by Kayleigh Dray
06 Dec 2016

The best A-list Instagrams from the week so far

From Lady Gaga's supermarket sweep to backstage at the British Fashion Awards

by Nicola Colyer
06 Dec 2016

Lady Gaga opens up about her struggle with PTSD

The singer says she is still dealing with the psychological impact of being raped.

by Moya Crockett
06 Dec 2016

Bernardo Bertolucci responds to Last Tango in Paris backlash

"This is a ridiculous misunderstanding"

by Kayleigh Dray
06 Dec 2016

Madonna twerks up a storm with James Corden in new Carpool Karaoke

Watch this material girl get up on the… dashboard?

by Kayleigh Dray
06 Dec 2016

How three women transformed their lives in wake of the Ebola crisis

A burial worker, a farmer and a mechanic on making it in a man's world

by Sarah Biddlecombe
05 Dec 2016

Jennifer Aniston reprises her role as Friends’ Rachel in epic video

It’s probably the closest we’re ever going to get to a Friends reunion

by Kayleigh Dray
05 Dec 2016

Amy Schumer to play Barbie in new live-action movie

But trolls have already slammed her as “too fat” for the role

by Kayleigh Dray
05 Dec 2016

Director admits controversial rape scene was real-life sexual assault

“I wanted her reaction as a girl, not as an actress”

by Kayleigh Dray
05 Dec 2016

The best A-list Instagrams from the week so far

From Reese Witherspoon's birthday shout-out to the Beckhams' glam evening

by Nicola Colyer
02 Dec 2016