Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation

“I'm not faking it”: woman's mental illness selfie goes viral


A woman has posed two selfies that highlight the danger of accusing mental health sufferers of ‘faking it.’

Anna Spargo-Ryan’s images were posed in response to an article in The Sydney Morning Herald that provided advice on how employers could spot whether or not an employee was ‘faking’ their mental illness to get time off work.

Incensed by the suggestion that anyone would want to ‘fake’ a mental illness, or that mental illness was visible in the same way that a physical illness is, Spargo-Ryan took to Facebook to post the two selfies next to one another, showing how her mental illness manifests itself visibly from day to day.

The first photograph shows Melbourne-based Spargo-Ryan crying – clearly distressed - and the second shows her apparently relaxed and happy.

Alongside the images, the writer posted:

“These photos of me were taken three days apart. In the first one, I have a mental illness. And in the second one, I have a mental illness.”

These photos of me were taken three days apart. In the first one, I have a mental illness. And in the second one, I...

Posted by Anna Spargo-Ryan on Friday, 22 January 2016

“Part of what makes mental illness so hard to identify in at-risk people is the constant reinforcement that we're 'imagining it' or that we're 'just sad' or that we 'have to want to get better,'” she continues.

“Good people have mental illnesses. We need them to feel supported and empowered in their places, whether that's work or home or school or somewhere else. Not that someone is waiting to 'catch them out'. Not that their illness is not legitimate. Not that the time they take away from work to seek treatment is bogus.

“Both of these photos are mental illness. I hope this helps you to spot the fakers,” she writes.

Spargo-Ryan’s post touched so many people that it has now been shared almost 1000 times on Facebook, with hundreds of comments below the image giving messages of support – and thanks.

One user posted saying:

“Most folk with mental illness spend much of their time and energy faking being WELL. That article disgusts me. Thank you Anna, you are too wise & fabulous for words Xx.”

Another said:

“I've spent the last day and a half in bed. Right now I'm feeling okay, and tomorrow I'll probably get stuff done. The symptoms come and go, the illness itself does not.”

The Sydney Morning Herald journalist, James Adonis, has since apologised for his article.

Taking to Twitter to say sorry for his assertion, Adonis wrote:

The journalist also issued a formal apology, saying:

“Since publishing this article, an enormous amount of feedback on social media has made me realise it was poorly written and insensitive. This has been unfair on those with a mental illness and their loved ones. This was never my intention. My intention was to achieve the opposite. At this I clearly failed. I'm genuinely sorry.”

If you or someone you loves suffers from mental illness, get in touch with the mental health charity, Mind,  for support. 


anxious child.jpg

“My childhood anxiety went untreated - and I'm still dealing with it”


Gillian Anderson on dealing with anxiety and going grey

illustration 1.jpg

Small moments of solitude we all cherish in our fast, frenetic world

blogger mum.JPG

Mother's message about dealing with post-natal depression goes viral

anxiety draw.JPG

Watch as people draw what it feels like to suffer from anxiety


Illustrator perfectly captures the everyday anxieties we all deal with


Woman explains exactly what depression is like in stunning poem

anna wyatt.JPG

The random act of kindness that helped this woman overcome anorexia


The one life-changing tip that will help you cope with stress



The best A-list Instagrams from the week so far

From Cindy Crawford's Halloween throwback to Alexa Chung's wild adventure

by Nicola Colyer
28 Oct 2016

Is this the Nineties girl band reunion we’ve been waiting for?

We don’t think you can handle this.

by Moya Crockett
28 Oct 2016

Pussy Riot’s new single is pro-vaginas and anti-Trump

“The idea of powerful female sexuality is much bigger than any populist megalomaniac man.”

by Moya Crockett
27 Oct 2016

Mamma Mia! ABBA confirm plans to reunite for “live experience” in 2018

All four of the original Dancing Queens are on board

by Kayleigh Dray
27 Oct 2016

Bake Off’s Mary Berry on her TV reunion with Mel and Sue

The future for these GBBO stars is very bright indeed…

by Kayleigh Dray
27 Oct 2016

Lady Gaga fans, the full Carpool Karaoke video is beyond incredible

James Corden’s face says it all, really

by Kayleigh Dray
27 Oct 2016

Sorry Mel C, Little Mix don't want you to be their mum

You can be ours though

by Anna Pollitt
26 Oct 2016

This Instagram star's honest selfie has gone viral

A glimpse behind the filtered curtain

by Amy Swales
26 Oct 2016

The Alexander McQueen biopic just cast the perfect Hollywood star

Another British bad boy.

by Moya Crockett
26 Oct 2016

Jennifer Garner opens up on co-parenting with ex-husband Ben Affleck

The pair try to teach their children the importance of charity

by Sarah Biddlecombe
26 Oct 2016