Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation

Lucy Mangan: "Men just can't handle a diet"


"My version: my husband is undergoing an infinitesimal alteration of his eating habits. His version: he is being starved to death.

For our purposes, let us split the difference and agree that he is on a diet. This is because a few weeks ago, he came across our wedding photos and noticed that, four years ago, he was thinner. Which meant that he was now fatter. ‘And this,’ I said, eyeing the gently rounded belly that now strains at the shirts he has been wearing since he was a student, ‘is news to you how?’

‘It’s ridiculous!’ he shouted.

‘It’s not so ridiculous,’ I pointed out. ‘You think mixing vegetable supernoodles with chunks of salami is a balanced meal. You drink beer. You’re nearly 40. And you haven’t taken any exercise since 1991. And that was chasing a chip van.’ He said he wanted to lose weight. I agreed to help him. The weeks since then have been an education for both of us.

My husband is an intelligent man. There’s nothing he doesn’t know about history, politics, current events. He reads voraciously and doesn’t just retain all the information he comes across but synthesises it and makes it an organic whole in his mind, instead of a mere series of facts. In the world of food, diets and nutrition, however, he is dumber than the toast he can no longer have while standing in front of the fridge deciding what he actually wants to eat for lunch.

I, on the other hand, can’t pick any politician (except spambot Cameron) or monarch (except Henry VIII, if he had his six wives standing next to him) out of a line-up, find Syria on a map or retain any fact I’ve read since my brain calcified overnight at 18. And yet, it turns out, I can knock out a bespoke weight-loss programme in seconds, using a reserve of information my husband swears he has never in his life heard the smallest mention of.

I’ve explained vitamins, the value of fibre, the need for stable blood sugar levels and not skipping meals. I’ve tried to explain the need to play the fat, fibre and glucose contents of each meal off against each other, why fizzy drinks are bad even if they have a sporty logo, and just why, mouthful for mouthful, salad is a better dietary tool than sausage.

It turns out I can knock out a bespoke weight loss programme in seconds

It’s actually been quite a frightening look at the difference between the worlds of men and women. I have begun to realise how much and how relentlessly I have been exposed (without seeking it out more than a handful of times in my life) to information – advice, recommendations, warnings – about what I should put into my body when and why. To me, food is a balancing act – every bite parsed for its calorie vs fat vs fibre vs reward vs punishment ratio to make sure it is justified and, if not, to be able to make the ‘necessary’ adjustments later on in the day or week. To him, the idea of food as anything other than simply a pleasurable way of providing him with energy has never crossed his mind.

I’ve never had an eating disorder. Food was never an ‘issue’ in our house. My mother never dieted or did anything other than stop me eating my own bodyweight in penny shrimps. I’ve never dieted ‘properly’ – and yet still, food to me is far from a friend, let alone simply the fuel my husband takes it to be.

In addition, he is utterly FURIOUS about having to amend his habits, whereas I only ever feel guilty that I haven’t. Food, I realise now, is something over which he naturally expects to have perfect and everlasting dominion – just like he does in the rest of his life. His reaction to the act of dieting has shown me not only how deep an incursion the dietary troops have made into female lives, minds and bodies but how much this pattern is repeated elsewhere. We accept and are conditioned to accept limitations on our appetites for money, for power, for equal opportunities at work, for the freedom to wear what we want and walk where we want without being abused or attacked – they are all of a piece. We curb and deny ourselves daily in a way that would outrage men if they were asked to do the same, as my husband in one tiny way is currently being asked to do. All of a sudden I find myself hungry for a slice of what he has.”

Photo credit: Rex Features



“If you need me, I’ll be in the woods”

Lucy Mangan on the joy of being alone

by Lucy Mangan
01 Mar 2017

Lucy Mangan explains how a tragic event can actually unite us all

“Amidst polarising opinion, we are still united”

by Lucy Mangan
01 Mar 2017

“Brace yourself – it’s time we had the baby chat”

Lucy Mangan on why it’s fine to not want children

by Lucy Mangan
01 Mar 2017

“You can take your heels and...”

Lucy Mangan on the high heels debate

by Lucy Mangan
01 Mar 2017

“All hail the big cosmetic surgery U-turn”

Lucy Mangan on a welcome change in the fashion and beauty industry

by Lucy Mangan
03 Feb 2017

“Without divorce, marriage is doomed”

Lucy Mangan on why the world needs divorce

by Lucy Mangan
01 Feb 2017

Lucy Mangan on the art of saving money

“In debt? Allow me to confiscate your cards”

by Lucy Mangan
15 Jan 2017

Lucy Mangan guides us into the New Year

“So here it is! 2017: a user’s manual”

by Lucy Mangan
01 Jan 2017

Lucy Mangan doles out her annual awards

“And the award for the worst year ever goes to...”

by Lucy Mangan
09 Dec 2016

Lucy Mangan on the hope in the abuse headlines

“The silence that protects people who do terrible things is breaking down”

by Lucy Mangan
05 Dec 2016