Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation
Top

“The red carpet isn’t the place for politics” Lucy Mangan on the Oscars #AskHerMore campaign

GettyImages-464191856.jpg

Should Hollywood's red carpet reporters change their interview tactics? Stylist columnist Lucy Mangan tackles a question that now has its very own hashtag campaign.

Could I make a plea about the Oscars? Could we not #AskHerMore this year? This is the campaign, launched a few years ago by The Representation Project (an organisation that seeks to expose and correct gender stereotypes in the media), to encourage people to ask women on the red carpet more searching questions than what or who they are wearing, and who loaned them their jewellery.

It’s a good and righteous campaign. But there’s a time and a place for everything and for this it is not on the Oscars red carpet.

Outside the Dolby Theatre – inside is different and we’ll get to that – is a fashion show. Everyone is dressed up to the nines, everyone looks beautiful, everyone is basically a work of art. So talk about the art. This is the one time of the year when it actually is appropriate to ask everyone who and what they’re wearing, who loaned them their jewels and how much the fabulous glittering ropes of diamonds and rubies are worth. Let us know what’s vintage Valentino and confirm that the glorious, impossible confection of frills and furbelows is Oscar de la Renta and point out what magic Balenciaga has conjured up this year. It’s fine.

Lucy Mangan

To do anything else is entirely wrong in the context, looks ridiculous and risks making the whole crusade look risible. As far as I’m concerned, on the Oscar red carpet, the only campaign should be #AskHimLess. Stick to asking the male actors the easy questions about clothes too. Although it should perhaps be called #AskHimEvenLess, because I’ve never seen even the men given much of a chance to show off their intellectual prowess by anything lobbed at them by Ryan Seacrest et al as they peg it down the red road to the safety of their seats. Of all the imbalances out there in the world, it really does seem fairly minimal here.

Off the carpet, things are of course different – even, as I say, once inside the venue the rules change. The mood is different. People are watching attentively. They have a platform conducive to coherent thought and often use it. Host Chris Rock will almost certainly – he may consider himself honour-bound – confront the extraordinary lack of people of colour among the nominees (the awareness of which was raised in part by another highly effective social media campaign #OscarsSoWhite). Winners may do likewise when they are in the spotlight. Equally, female winners may choose to use their speeches to poke fun/get angry about Hollywood’s equally abject failure to give women parity in pay, respect or screen time and narrative heft. By all means boys, do likewise.

Beyond the Oscars, #AskHerMore can and should keep the pressure on interviewers to ask all actors about their work rather than their diets, partners and latest break-ups. Whether you want them to be asked about current affairs depends on where you stand on actors’ ability to see further into a geopolitical conflict than the rest of us. Personally I’m not convinced that just because an actor has played a terrorist or an activist or a politician they are any more qualified than I am to pronounce upon world crises and I could be easily persuaded that there is more integrity in just letting us know how they maintain three per cent body fat without throwing themselves off a cliff in hungry despair, but your mileage may vary.

In the meantime, on Oscar night let’s keep our powder dry and just admire the dresses on the catwalk while we #AskThemAllTheSame.


Lava lamp

I am renting a cottage in Norfolk for a week (because I’m supposed to be writing a book and this is not proving possible at home) and in it is something quite marvellous. I literally sit here and marvel at it. It is a lava lamp. It brings me a peace like I have never known. I begin to understand why people go on about meditation (though not why they do so at quite such length). I sit here at the end of the day and watch it instead of the telly. It concentrates the mind wonderfully. My whole world narrows down to the fascinating question of what sized blob will detach itself from the molten mass and how far it will rise before gravity reasserts itself and brings it down to earth once more. No matter how the day has gone it takes me completely out of my messy head in a way nothing else has ever managed. As a lifelong hater of hippies and all their associated things, this is disconcerting. But another look at my lamp soothes me again. When I get home I’m buying one of my own. The new me starts here.


Photography: Ellis Parrinder, Getty

To read this week's issue of Stylist, download from app.stylist.co.uk

Related

KateWinslet.jpg

Kate Winslet offers inspiring speech to women who doubt themselves

jada pinkett smith.jpg

Oscars to tackle lack of diversity after stars threaten boycott

cate blanchett.jpg

Cate Blanchett reveals the not-so-glamorous side of the Golden Globes

rexfeatures_5407514o.jpg

Dakota Johnson slams ageism in Hollywood

rexfeatures_5586116ac-2.jpg

BAFTAs 2016: Celebrity red carpet arrivals

rexfeatures_5505654c.jpg

The Oscars 2016 nominations announced: see who's up for an award

opener_rt.jpg

Hollywood's newest star Brie Larson chats Oscars buzz

susan sarandon.jpg

Susan Sarandon has the perfect response to Piers Morgan’s body shaming

sag-awards-2016 hero.jpg

SAG Awards 2016: red carpet fashion highlights

Comments

More

Lucy Mangan on why feeling beautiful starts with your thoughts

“Erase the ugly voices in your head”

by Lucy Mangan
01 Apr 2017

“A step-by-step guide to sexism”: Lucy Mangan responds to ‘Legs-it’

You are a lady and you have legs. Use them to kick ass.

by Lucy Mangan
01 Apr 2017

“If you need me, I’ll be in the woods”

Lucy Mangan on the joy of being alone

by Lucy Mangan
01 Mar 2017

Lucy Mangan explains how a tragic event can actually unite us all

“Amidst polarising opinion, we are still united”

by Lucy Mangan
01 Mar 2017

“Brace yourself – it’s time we had the baby chat”

Lucy Mangan on why it’s fine to not want children

by Lucy Mangan
01 Mar 2017

“You can take your heels and...”

Lucy Mangan on the high heels debate

by Lucy Mangan
01 Mar 2017

“All hail the big cosmetic surgery U-turn”

Lucy Mangan on a welcome change in the fashion and beauty industry

by Lucy Mangan
03 Feb 2017

“Without divorce, marriage is doomed”

Lucy Mangan on why the world needs divorce

by Lucy Mangan
01 Feb 2017

“In these uncertain times we all need to steady each other”

Lucy Mangan is exasperated by the election

by Lucy Mangan
01 Feb 2017

Lucy Mangan on the art of saving money

“In debt? Allow me to confiscate your cards”

by Lucy Mangan
15 Jan 2017