Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation
Top

Women share their 'smiles' after news host tells Hillary Clinton to cheer up

smileforjoe.jpg

Bidding for leadership of the free world is a serious business, but a major network news host is of the opinion Hillary Clinton should cheer up [love] about it.

MSNBC's Joe Scarborough was firing out Twitter observances on Primary Day when he spotted something important. Clinton had just won the Missouri primary and was not smiling!

Hillary Clinton

Hillary Clinton. Not smiling for Joe.

The backlash against Scarborough's ill-advised comment was immediate and brilliant, with women everywhere taking up the challenge to #SmileForJoe.

An explosion of selfies showed women's glowering, bemused and incredulous responses:

Aside from the condescending and demanding tone in Scarborough's tweet, there's the subtle implication that Clinton should show gratitude for her win. Would Scarborough have turned smile police if it had been Bernie Sanders making the victory speech? 

Nah, a serious, finger-stabbing, tie-wearing man is above such irrelevancies. Women, on the other hand, well we just look more approachable and receptive when we smile. It's remiss of us to not to.

Antagonistic call outs in the vein of Scarborough's have long been a pain for women. Many articles over the past decade have picked over the sexist street remarks "smile" and "cheer up" women get from men they don't know. 

Even the type of men who still say them, dressing it up as banter, are now probably aware they're a cliche. For an influential news host to use the line on the woman who could be President is breathtaking. It's like Tom Bradby saying the Home Secretary should smile when she's introducing a new bill in the House of Commons.

Scarborough is not sorry for his tweet. He responded at length to the #SmileForJoe campaign with a column in The Washington Postin which he says he would never tell a woman walking down the street to smile, but was "critiquing" Clinton's political skills.

He also included a sarcastic defence that his tweet isn't as bad as it could have been.

"My seven-word tweet was the greatest offence committed against womankind since misogynists like Henry VIII and Bobby Riggs roamed the earth.” - Joe Scarborough

He regularly praises Clinton and often gives Trump and other male politicians a hard time, he argues.

But he misses the point that it is always criticism addressing their actions, never their looks.

Related

thinkstockphotos-467037208.jpg

At last, tampon tax set to be scrapped after EU deal

rexfeatures_5490371da.jpg

Olivia Wilde deemed “too old” to play Leonardo DiCaprio's wife

dwlm.jpg

Why IS Louise Minchin still in the 'inferior' seat?

iStock_000061462728_Medium.jpg

This is the world’s happiest country in 2016

Hend-Krichen-21-9-153695.jpg

12 tableware dining sets to make your meals more Instagrammable

bridemaids.jpg

The alarming reason bridesmaids traditionally wear matching dresses

iStock_000059737178_Medium.jpg

Middle class pick up lines take the internet by storm

shared parental leave.png

Breaking down the budget: what does it mean for women?

rexfeatures_5593469fr.jpg

Does Adele have the best stage chat of them all?

Comments

More

People share messages of defiance after Manchester terror attack

“Don't be afraid. Dance until you're dizzy”

by Sarah Biddlecombe
23 May 2017

The Royal Family thank people of Manchester following terror attack

“I would like to express my admiration for the way the people of Manchester have responded”

by Amy Swales
23 May 2017

Theresa May responds to Manchester terror attack

“Britain's spirit will never be broken”

by Sarah Biddlecombe
23 May 2017

“We stand by your side”: the world responds to the Manchester attack

“We can do little more, but we are here. Solidarity has no frontiers.“

by Kayleigh Dray
23 May 2017

Pippa Middleton’s wedding: all the pictures

The gown, the guests, the royal bridal party

21 May 2017

Gal Gadot explains why the new Wonder Woman is a feminist film

"People have a misconception about what feminism is"

by Moya Crockett
19 May 2017

Robin Wright is still receiving less pay for House of Cards role

She believed she was awarded the same pay as Kevin Spacey in 2016

by Jasmine Andersson
18 May 2017

“How renting out my spare room changed my life”

Four women reveal the transformative experiences they had through Airbnb

by Amy Swales
18 May 2017

Jennifer Lawrence has the best response to leaked pole dancing video

“I'm not going to apologise, I had a BLAST"

by Sarah Biddlecombe
18 May 2017

Solange Knowles writes powerful open letter to her teenage self

The star has a few words to say on the power of the female

18 May 2017