Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation

Woman wins legal battle over using her deceased daughter's eggs to have a baby


A 60-year-old woman who wants to give birth to her deceased daughter’s child has won a legal battle in the Court of Appeal.

The woman’s “much-loved and only” daughter, referred to in court as A, died of bowel cancer in 2011 at the age of 28. She was said to have been desperate to have children and wanted to have IVF treatment, but became too ill: the last five years of her life were spent in hospital.

After A suggested that her ovaries be transplanted into her mother, three of her eggs were removed and stored.

However, the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA) originally refused to allow the mother, known as Mrs M, to carry out her daughter’s wishes, saying that she had not given explicit written permission.

Now, the Court of Appeal has ordered the HFEA to reconsider Mrs M’s application – meaning that she may now be able to take A’s eggs to an American fertility clinic to be used with donor sperm.

Mrs M and her husband first launched legal action against the refusal in 2014. Their lawyers said that the eggs would perish if the HFEA’s ruling was not overturned.


The daughter's eggs would be shipped to the US to be mixed with donor sperm in a fertility clinic

Jenni Richards QC, speaking for the parents, argued that it was unreasonable to expect A to do more when she was dying from cancer, and that she had never been given the consent form which she supposedly needed to have signed for the procedure to go ahead.

“It would be wrong to use the consent form that she was not given to defeat [her] wishes as expressed on the form she did sign and subsequently in conversation with her mother and friends,” she said.

The three judges presiding over the appeal believed that Mrs M had thought her daughter had signed all the necessary forms.

Catherine Callaghan, speaking for the HFEA, said that it had sympathy for Mrs and Mr M’s loss and understood their desire to keep A’s memory alive. She said: “The law requires us to consider whether there is sufficient evidence of informed consent. After looking at the matter in great detail we decided that there wasn’t, a decision which was supported by the High Court last September.

“Today’s judgement by the Court of Appeal reaffirms the need for informed consent but concludes that there is sufficient evidence of Mr and Mrs M’s daughter’s true wishes.”

However, the judges’ decision this time around only rules that the original refusal was a misjudgement. It does not mean that the parents will definitely be able to seek fertility treatment in the US.

The HFEA said it would reconsider the case as soon as possible.

Images: iStock



Woman battles to use her deceased daughter's eggs to conceive a child


Why one woman chose to extract sperm after her husband's sudden death

Human embryo scientific research

“Science rocks. And so does being British…”


The stigma of having an abortion later in life


“How I came to be voluntarily infertile aged 30”

Credit Suszi Lurie McFadden.jpg

Widow, Lucy Kalanithi, on how to grieve and breathe after death


10 women chosen to trial Britain’s first womb transplant


Widow wins High Court battle to preserve late husband's sperm

103785024 (1).jpg

Facebook and Apple to offer free egg freezing to employees


This massive star was very nearly in Hocus Pocus

Oh sisters, how very different things could have been

by Nicola Colyer
20 Oct 2017

Quentin Tarantino on not doing more to stop Harvey Weintsein

“I knew enough to do more than I did”

by Nicola Colyer
20 Oct 2017

Lupita Nyong’o says she was harassed by Harvey Weinstein as a student

“He told me not to be so naïve. If I wanted to be an actress, then I had to be willing to do this sort of thing.”

by Moya Crockett
20 Oct 2017

Mary Berry takes part in heartbreaking film about child bereavement

“I would thank him for being a brilliant son.”

by Amy Swales
20 Oct 2017

Margot Robbie writes stirring open letter to Hollywood

by Nicola Colyer
19 Oct 2017

Gabrielle Union shares a powerful message about rape and harassment

The star says she’ll “keep talking out” for survivors like herself

by Susan Devaney
19 Oct 2017

Why the singer has opened up about her mental health

The singer says it was “really, really bad” during her time with the band

by Susan Devaney
19 Oct 2017

The best A-list Instagrams from the week so far

From Madonna’s touching tribute to a Cruel Intentions reunion

by Nicola Colyer
19 Oct 2017

Anna Faris understands why people were obsessed with her relationship

She and Chris Pratt were often hailed as #relationshipgoals

by Amy Swales
19 Oct 2017

Cher is starring in the Mamma Mia! sequel and we can’t wait for 2018

Can you hear the drums, Fernando?

by Susan Devaney
18 Oct 2017