Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation
Top

Blackpool hotel fines couple £100 for scathing Tripadvisor review of "rotten stinking hovel"

broadway-hotel.jpg

The whole point of travel review website Tripadvisor is that you voice your opinion and write what you really think.

But one couple ended up with a £100 fine for doing exactly that.

Tony and Jan Jenkinson wrote a scathing review of Broadway Hotel in Blackpool after staying there for one night in August.

The retired couple, from Whitehaven in Cumbria, paid £36 for the night but later found they had been charged an extra £100 to their credit card. The hotel said it was its policy to charge for bad reviews.

Its booking form contains the clause: "Despite the fact that repeat customers and couples love our hotel, your friends and family may not. For every bad review left on any website, the group organiser will be charged a maximum £100 per review."

tripadvisor review

An extract from the review

The couple's review, posted on 30 August, described the Blackpool hotel as "a filthy, dirty, rotten, stinking hovel".

They claim the hot tap in their room didn't work, the kettle was broken, the front of the cupboard drawer fell off when they opened it, the carpet was dirty and stained and "the mattress attacked you in the night".

Breakfast was apparently "a joke" with "plastic sausages".

"This place should be shut down, I don't know if they are ever inspected, but if so, I don't know how this place has passed!" the review concluded. "If you are offered this place to stay for a fortnight for 10p, you are being robbed! STAY AWAY!"

Other reviewers on the site were also unimpressed, describing the Broadway Hotel as "lacking basic cleanliness", "horrific" and "a disgusting place".

A total of 147 Tripadvisor guests rated the place as terrible, but a handful thought it was excellent. 

"A warm welcome on arrival , shown to room which had a clear view of the seafront. Linen was fresh and changed daily," reads one review from April this year (the writer had 54 reviews to his name).

Blackpool couple

Mr and Mrs Jenkinson speaking to the BBC

Mr and Mrs Jenkinson were on their way to Oxford when they decided to split the journey by staying in Blackpool. They said they only chose the hotel because it had parking space. Mrs Jenkinson didn't have her glasses on so she signed the booking form without reading the review clause.

"Annoyed isn't strong enough for how I feel about this, what happened to freedom of speech?" Mr Jenkinson told the BBC. "Everybody we have spoken to says they [the hotel] are not allowed to do this."

Trading Standards are investigating the case. 

Regional manager John Greenbank said the clause was a "novel" way to prevent bad reviews. 

"I have worked for trading standards for many years and have never seen anything like this," he said.

The hotel owner has not returned requests for comment. 

Blackpool

Blackpool

What do you think? Have you ever received any response from writing a negative hotel review on TripAdvisor? Or maybe you run your own hotel - in which case, how do you deal with negative reviews? Let us know your thoughts in the comments section below. 

Related

rexfeatures_948033a.jpg

20 opening lines from our favourite Christmas books

porridge.jpg

Your seven day gluten-free meal plan: delicious daily recipes

rexfeatures_411192c.jpg

Colin Farrell makes heartfelt plea for marriage equality in Ireland

Comments

More

The adventure-hungry pilot encouraging female aviators everywhere

Eser Aksan Erdogan is high on life

by Anna Brech
17 Feb 2017

Need solo travel inspiration? Find your dream destination here

City break or beach holiday...?

by Sarah Biddlecombe
16 Feb 2017

Where to go in spring: the best holidays for March, April and May

Insider knowledge on falling prices, the best springtime skiing and avoiding tourist hordes

by Amy Swales
15 Feb 2017

The 12 hippest European neighbourhoods to visit this year

Coffee shops, vintage boutiques, and outsider art, from Athens to Oslo.

by Moya Crockett
14 Feb 2017

Soak up sea views and culture in Barcelona

Stylist's entertainment editor Helen Bownass rediscovers Barcelona's cool

by Helen Bownass
07 Feb 2017

There's a new Gin School and we're desperate to enrol

Me please, Miss

by Kayleigh Dray
01 Feb 2017

A winter wonderland in the Canadian Rockies

As Canada celebrates its 150th birthday, Stylist’s Sue Fowler straps on her skis and tours the Rockies.

by The Stylist web team
31 Jan 2017

Who needs the Caribbean? The best islands in the UK

Time to book that time off work and enjoy a staycation

by Deborah Cicurel
30 Jan 2017

LA to launch sexual harassment hotline on public transport

It's the first city in the world to launch a dedicated hotline

by Sarah Biddlecombe
18 Jan 2017

Enjoy London in style - and on a budget

Soaking up London's cultural delights needn't cost the earth finds Stylist's photographer and specialist director, Tom Gormer

by The Stylist web team
17 Jan 2017