Jump to Main ContentJump to Primary Navigation

Airline passengers should pay each other for right to recline, study claims


Up there with speedy boarders (the worst) and parking so far away from the airport you’re practically in another time zone, another major gripe of modern air travel is someone reclining their seat in front of you.

We’ve all done it, of course, just some more than others. Whether you’re one of the faceless cowards who drop their chairs before the seatbelt sign has even been turned off, or the politer kind who at least wait until the middle of the flight before having the audacity to sprawl back and make someone’s difficult airline meal even more difficult, or just someone who opts against it out of principal, there’s no denying the right to recline continues to provoke debate.

Well it’s now reached new heights, with a study in the US finding that passengers should pay each other for the right to recline their chair.

In a series of experiments by New York-based law professors Christopher Buccafusco and Christopher Jon Sprigman, the pair discovered that people would demand on average $18 (£14) to stop the person in front reclining their seat, and claimed this bargaining could even be done through the purchasing of on-flight snacks.

When they asked if passengers would be prepared to take a snack or drink not to recline, the study found that 78 per cent of the people in front were willing to accept it, with 36 per cent willing to take the offer.

 “Nobody likes the recent turn toward airlines charging for every service, but maybe what we need is more of that,” they wrote.

Read more: Remembering the golden age when air travel was actually glamorous

"Most airlines still hand out free drinks, and sometimes little bags of pretzels. Maybe instead they should charge for them and allow passengers to purchase them for one another.

“Everyone wins. Seat recline space is efficiently allocated. Airlines are marginally further from bankruptcy. And no one gets punched in the face.”

That’s no overstatement. Unlike many short haul carriers in the UK, such as Easyjet and Ryanair, whose bulky chairs offer about as much flexibility as Jackie Stallone’s facial muscles, many airlines in the US still offer full-on reclining chairs, leading to spats on an almost daily basis.

Around two years ago the issue only worsened when passengers in ‘cattle class’ fought back by using a new product called the Knee Defender - a small detachable device which prevents those in front of you from dropping their seat back – which naturally sparked even numerous mid-air rows.

Although it proved bad press for the airlines, news of the incidents only made the product more popular, with orders soon coming in from across the globe – yep, even the UK.

Read more: 10 proven ways to cure your phobia of flying and getting on board

As for charging to recline, perhaps airlines could implement a pre-boarding online booking form for passengers to indicate if they’d happily let someone recline in return for food. That could work. We hear United Airlines could do with some good press.

Or here’s a crazy idea, guys: how about giving people sitting in economy actual leg room? That could do it.

Images: iStock



Laptops are set to be banned on all flights from Europe to the US

solo female travelling.jpg

The 7 best trips to take as an intrepid solo-traveller

air steward.jpg

Flight attendants claim they were paid less due to their weight


Find yourself a hotel deal with Mr & Mrs Smith

22 Oct 2017

See red in Koh Samui

Stylist heads to Thailand to experience one of the most spectacular swimming pools in the world

by The Stylist web team
17 Oct 2017

You're more likely to get better service on a plane if you sit here

We've got all the in-flight seating tips you could ever want

by Megan Murray
16 Oct 2017

These are the 10 happiest places to live in the UK

Is it time for a change of scenery?

by Susan Devaney
11 Oct 2017

Discover a Costwolds bolthole with museum-worthy art

Stylist finds Artist Residence Oxfordshire more than lives up to its name

by Amy Adams
10 Oct 2017

The 10 dreamiest (and most expensive) streets to live on in the UK

We should have started saving about ten years ago

by Megan Murray
04 Oct 2017

Discover the real Rome that lies beyond the silver screen

Stylist goes behind the scenes at the living film set that is Rome

by The Stylist web team
03 Oct 2017

Seriously hip hotels you need to follow on Instagram

From a rock’n’roll hideaway in Texas to a futuristic glampsite in Devon

by Anna Hart
28 Sep 2017

Step between the scenes of Australia’s artsy second city…

Melbourne shuns beaches and boardwalks for coffee, culture and creativity, finds Stylist

by The Stylist web team
26 Sep 2017

This is how to book an NYC shopping trip with Sarah Jessica Parker

Sex and the City fans, this is not a drill

by Megan Murray
26 Sep 2017