After launching last September with three episodes, The Way Down became the streamer’s most watched docuseries debut, which explains why we’re now getting a scripted spin-off.

Paulson, of course, has excellent form when it comes to impersonations. In 2016, she scooped an Emmy award for her career-defining turn as Marcia Clark in The People V. OJ Simpson: American Crime Story, and was recently nominated again for her portrayal of Linda Tripp in Ryan Murphy’s Impeachment: American Crime Story.

There aren’t too many details on the project so far as it’s still in development. However, Michelle Dean, who recently served as showrunner and exec producer of Hulu’s The Act, starring Patricia Arquette and Joey King, will serve as showrunner and executive producer of the new series, so it’s fair to say we’ve got big expectations. And come 2023, Paulson could well have another Emmy nomination on her hands.

The Way Down: Sarah Paulson is starring as an infamous cult leader in a new adaptation of HBO’s hit docuseries