Gentleman Jack recap: 5 things we learned in episode 4

Posted by
Meena Alexander
backgroundLayer 1
Add this article to your list of favourites
Gentleman Jack: Sophie Rundle is a tearful Ann Walker

Suranne Jones and Sophie Rundle give their most heart-rending performances yet in episode 4 of Gentleman Jack, when a chilling secret threatens to tear Anne Lister and Ann Walker apart.

In the last episode we got roses, and in this episode came the thorns. 

We always knew our heroine’s love for wealthy heiress Ann Walker would come with its fair share of obstacles – this is a 19th-century society in which the word lesbian doesn’t even exist, after all – yet up until now their tentative secret romance just added to the excitement. 

But in episode 4 we get a serious reality check: it’s clear that women, especially women who love women, are never really safe in a world that lends so much power to men.

Here are five things we learned:

You may also like

Gentleman Jack: everything we know about Suranne Jones’ new miniseries

Anne and Ann are in very real danger

After everyone’s least favourite busybody, Eliza Priestley, bursts in on the lovers in episode 3, it’s not long before she’s told half of Halifax about it. 

As self-empowered as Anne Lister is, she’s not stupid: she knows that living openly as a lesbian will incur abuse and disgust from high society and lead to many doors being slammed in her face – and Anne is an ambitious woman. 

She urges Ann to “behave as normal” to try to quell the rumours, but we quickly realise that there is a threatening undertone to the gossip flying around the town. Mrs Priestley references the “two men who were hanged” recently and Ann’s aunt and uncle use an accusatory and hostile tone to suggest Anne has their niece “under her spell”. 

The deep-rooted homophobia within society is starting to overshadow the love story – and it’s sadly all too relevant.

Gentleman Jack: Stephanie Cole as the judgemental Aunt Ann Walker
Gentleman Jack: Stephanie Cole as the judgemental Aunt Ann Walker

They weren’t too hot on mental health in 1832

Wow, do these 19th-century doctors have a lot to learn. 

We’ve had a vague sense that Ann Walker is regarded as weak or fragile by many people, and there has been odd mentions of her needing to see the local doctor about “nerves, a nerve thing, nervy business” – whatever that means. 

However, after news of a friend’s death sends her into a panic, Anne suggests she visit a well-respected doctor and asks how she can help her lover to recover.

This supposedly genius doctor comes up with the diagnosis of “nervous hysteria” – ye olde manspeak for ‘over-emotional woman’ – but his suggestion that Anne is the “best thing that ever happened to her” seems to be about right. As we see at the end of this episode, Anne is the most supportive and understanding companion Ann Walker has ever had.

Poor Marian can’t catch a break

Oh Marian. Not only must you live in your sparkling sister’s shadow, you must also live in it alone. 

After their bust-up in the last episode, Marian comes to Anne with an unusual peace offering: she offers to sew her some underwear. She also reacts warmly to the idea of Ann moving in to Shibden Hall, which we think is pretty cool of her. 

But Anne doesn’t reciprocate this sisterly feeling when mention of Marian’s prospective beau (“But Jeremy, he makes carpets,” Aunt Anne bemoaned when Marian tried to get her father’s blessing), instead sneering at his lowly career. 

“I must question the pedigree of a man who makes rugs,” sniffs Anne. Brutal.

Gentleman Jack: Suranne Jones as the inspirational Anne Lister
Gentleman Jack: Suranne Jones as the inspirational Anne Lister

 Nothing gets in the way of Anne’s ambition 

Still battling with the villainous Rawson brothers over her coal pits, Anne decides she must become fully educated on mining if she is going to outwit them. Even amid serious upset in her personal life, she’s all business.

She demands to be taken down a pit, where she gets her hands dirty and talks business, much to the bemusement of the workers – one of which keeps calling her “Mister”. 

The experience bolsters her confidence in beating the Rawsons at their own game and regaining control of the coal on her estate. As her lawyer tells her: “Christopher Rawson is a bully. But if anyone is equal to him, it’s you.” We feel a win coming on.

Sign up for our essential edit of what to buy, see, read and do, and also receive a free guide to the 101 Female Authors Everyone Should Have On Their Bookshelf.

By entering my email I agree to Stylist’s Privacy Policy

Ann’s tragic secret ultimately brings them closer

The bomb of the episode arrives in the form of a letter to Ann from Reverend Ainsworth, who tells her that his wife – her friend – has died. 

This throws Ann into a downward spiral, which we first assume to be about the bereavement. But it soon emerges that the reverend wants to marry Ann while his poor wife is still warm in the ground.

At first, this rattles Anne, and her jealousy is evident. She sarcastically tells Ann to consider the proposal, which would mean she could marry, have children and “really fulfil your destiny on this planet as a woman”.

But then the awful truth comes out, that Ann has been raped and abused by Reverend Ainsworth and now feels “under an obligation to him”. 

Gentleman Jack: Suranne Jones and Sophie Rundle as Anne Lister and Ann Walker
Suranne Jones and Sophie Rundle as Anne Lister and Anne Walker in Gentleman Jack.

Her turmoil is enough to make you shed an angry tear, and that’s exactly what Anne does as she comforts and reassures her lover that she will protect her at all costs. 

“What are you going to do to him?” Ann asks. “I haven’t decided yet,” Anne says menacingly to camera. We can’t wait to see him get what he deserves.

Gentleman Jack continues next Sunday at 9pm on BBC One

Images: BBC One


Share this article


Meena Alexander

Meena Alexander is Stylist magazine’s features editor.

Recommended by Meena Alexander


Gentleman Jack recap: five things we learned in episode 3

Drama. Intrigue. Petticoats.

Posted by
Meena Alexander

Suranne Jones’s unanswered question to her late mum is relatable to anyone whose parent has dementia

“She would put her top on back to front”

Posted by
Hollie Richardson

Everything we know about the Downton Abbey film so far

The first full-length trailer has dropped and we couldn't be more excited.

Posted by
Nicola Rachel Colyer