This viral Twitter thread explains what really happens when women smile on demand

Posted by
Hannah-Rose Yee
backgroundLayer 1
Add this article to your list of favourites

Writer Robyn Wilder has detailed what really happens when a woman acquiesces to a man’s request to ‘smile’, and it’s truly sobering. 

“Hey darling, why don’t you give us a smile?”

Those words, or a variation of them, will be familiar to many women who have experienced street harassment. For the men who say them, the request is simple. Just a smile, a simple smile. What could be the harm in that?

Plenty, according to writer Robyn Wilder, who has detailed the escalating street harassment she has experienced every single time she has smiled at a man on the street who asked her to. She’s been followed, shouted at, experienced verbal abuse and had men try to kiss her. All because she smiled. 

You may also like

Why it’s high time we stop telling women to smile

“Yesterday a man stopped me as I was walking through the park, gestured for me to remove my earphones, then - when I did - asked: “Why don’t you smile more, love?”, so here’s a thread inevitably entitled THINGS THAT HAVE HAPPENED WHEN I HAVE SMILED POLITELY AT MEN I DON’T KNOW,” she wrote on Twitter

Wilder shared seven examples, before explaining that she had hundreds more. In one of them, a man on the overground train in the morning – Wilder was on her way to work – suggested they find a hotel room. In another, she was called “slag” and “pricktease” as she walked to her office.

“Just as a reminder, all I have done at this point - in any of these situations - is offer a small, polite smile,” Wilder tweeted.

She added: “I have 100 more examples of unwanted male approaches, AS DO MOST WOMEN. I am not an anomaly. This is why we shut down our fucking faces when there’s a man around that we don’t know, purely in the hope that we can go about our day unmolested.”

“Although also, WHY THE FUCK SHOULD I SMILE FOR YOU? I am not scenery. Go and look at a fucking sunset,” she concluded.  

Street harassment: why asking women to smile is so threatening.

Since sharing her thread, Wilder’s tweets have been liked or retweeted more than 2,500 times. Several Twitter users have used Wilder’s thread as a jumping off point for sharing their own experiences. (Some trolls, though have taken to commenting #NeverHappened underneath the thread, but the less said about them the better.)

Aside from exposing the horrors of street harassment, this thread details the huge problem with people who feel entitled to ask a woman to smile.

It’s not just women in the street who have had to endure the request. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez was criticised for not being “warm” enough at Trump’s State of the Union Address. (Her response? “Why should I be ‘spirited and warm’ for this embarrassment of a State of the Union? Tonight was an unsettling night for our country. The president failed to offer any plan, any vision at all, for our future. We’re flying without a pilot. And I’m not here to comfort anyone about that fact.”)

Critics have demanded that Greta Thunberg smile more. They wanted Captain Marvel to smile more. They decried Hillary Clinton for not plastering a rictus grin to her face at all times. They laid into Chelsea Handler for not being cheerful enough.

Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez delivering a speech at the Women’s March in New York.

Handler’s response was on point, actually: “Who the fuck are you to tell someone to smile? This is just another example of how men feel like they can belittle every woman in the world and order up a smile. It’s not just Hillary; they tell actresses to smile, they tell female athletes to smile… even paintings aren’t safe.”

“So here’s my message to all men,” Handler concluded. “Stop telling women to smile. We don’t like that - it’s not an icebreaker, it’s a dealbreaker. And what is your game plan anyway? Do you think we’re gonna go smile and then magically float onto your penis? It doesn’t work that way. Do you know how sexist that is to say that to us? No one ever tells a man to smile. Try it. Go tell Samuel L Jackson to turn that front upside down.”

The point is that no woman owes it to anyone to give them a smile. And yet women are constantly expected to smile because it is part of the gendered social contract of likeability that women are beholden to by the patriarchy. Men who expect these smiles from women on the street are treating women like objects whose emotions exist purely for others.

Sign up for the latest news and must-read features from Stylist, so you don't miss out on the conversation.

By entering my email I agree to Stylist’s Privacy Policy

And yet, when women smile because it is demanded of them, they can expose themselves to even more dangerous street harassment, as Wilder’s thread revealed. So no wonder, then, that so many women keep their head down as they walk through the streets.

No wonder, then, that for so many women that ‘harmless’ request for a smile can feel like a threat. 

Images: Unsplash, Getty


Share this article


Hannah-Rose Yee

Hannah-Rose Yee is a writer based in London. You can find her on the internet talking about movies, television and Chris Pine.

Recommended by Hannah-Rose Yee

Visible Women

“Stop telling Greta Thunberg to smile: she has every right to be angry”

Powerful men have told Greta Thunberg to “cheer up” – but she doesn’t owe her smile to anyone.

Posted by
Moya Crockett

Why it’s high time we stop telling women to smile

Don’t tell us to smile. Ever.

Posted by
Rhiannon Lucy Cosslett
Lucy Mangan

“Why it’s time to put our smiles on strike”

Lucy Mangan on taking a break from emotional labour

Posted by
Stylist Team

Why it's time to take a stand against Bitchy Resting Face

“Gizza smile love, it may never happen” by Alice Stride

Posted by
Stylist Team

Brie Larson brilliantly claps back at sexist trolls who want Captain Marvel to ‘smile’

“Breaking news: You can be you.”

Posted by
Susan Devaney