Stone and Lawrence previously told Vanity Fair that they got each other’s numbers from mutual co-star Woody Harrelson.

However, in a recent interview with W magazine, the duo revealed that things got real when they finally decided to meet in person.

“Jennifer Lawrence and I both had the same stalker, John the Orchestra Guy,” Stone explained.

“He would text us both and say things like ‘I’m running late on my way to the soundstage. Can you warm up the orchestra for me? Text me back and let me know you got this.’ He wasn’t really a stalker. He must have worked at a studio or something because he had a lot of people’s numbers.”

Eventually, Lawrence and Stone decided to meet up after a few years of dealing with John the Orchestra guy – although, naturally, they were both more than a little suspicious about the other.

Jennifer Lawrence has the best excuse for bailing on the 2018 Golden Globes