Mean Girls: the infuriating reason we didn’t see Lizzy Caplan in more TV shows and films

Posted by
Hollie Richardson
backgroundLayer 1
Add this article to your list of favourites
Mean Girls: Lizzie Caplan.

Lizzy Caplan has revealed the truth about why she couldn’t get more roles after playing Janis Ian in Mean Girls, and it exposes a big problem in the industry.

Janis Ian is iconic. The Mean Girls character joined forces with new girl Cady Heron and Damian Leigh to take down “those bitches” – The Plastics. For some, this made her a 00s hero, defying the personal and physical attributes that were considered to make a girl popular in a western high school. However, others have questioned if Janis was the real villain of the movie (see this Twitter thread for an admittedly well-backed case). Either way: her sharp one-liners, no-nonsense attitude and cutting comebacks created an unforgettable character. 

You may also like

Regina George wasn’t the real villain in Mean Girls, Janis Ian was

But for the actor who played Janis, Lizzy Caplan, playing the “comical” role had a dark side. Caplan has opened up about the reality of being typecast after Mean Girls – and it’s not so fetch.

Speaking to The Independent, Caplan explained how things have positively changed for female comedy actors in high school roles. “There wasn’t as much room for people more interested in doing things that were left of centre, or identified as something other than either the super popular girl or the dork or whatever,” she said

Mean Girls: Lizzie Caplan as Janis Ian.
Mean Girls: Lizzie Caplan as Janis Ian.

“Those archetypes felt a lot stronger back then, and I feel like there’s a shift now,” she added. “A lot of the actresses that are playing those parts, like Elsie [Fisher] and [Booksmart’s] Beanie Feldstein and Kaitlyn Dever – all of these girls are doing way more interesting shit, and they’re just way more interesting actresses than the ones that were around when I was that age.”

Caplan also explained how the role left her typecast, which led her to feel compelled to make personal physical changes. 

You may also like

Mean Girls Musical: Tina Fey has shared an update on the new film, and it sounds so fetch

“I remember after Mean Girls I didn’t work again for a long time,” she continued. “For like a year, I couldn’t get a job. The next thing I did, I straight up dyed my hair blonde and got a spray tan.”

Caplan added: “If they made Mean Girls now, I think that character would not be so pushed aside for future roles,” she suggests. “There’d be more opportunities for somebody playing the weird goth girl in a movie than there was back then.”

She did eventually go on to star in hit shows Masters of Sex and True Blood, but Caplan has described that as a “lucky ticket”. The fact that she describes it like this instead of putting it down to talent and hard work shows just how infuriatingly tough it is in the industry.

If you do want to catch Caplan in her latest series, you can watch Castle Rock on Amazon. 

Sign up for our essential edit of what to buy, see, read and do, and also receive our 11-page Ultimate Guide To Making Your Home Feel Bigger.

By entering my email I agree to Stylist’s Privacy Policy

Images: Getty, Paramount


Share this article


Hollie Richardson

Hollie is a digital writer at, mainly covering the daily news on women’s issues, politics, celebrities and entertainment. She also keeps an ear out for the best podcast episodes to share with readers. Oh, and don’t even get her started on Outlander…