Netflix’s Dirty John season 2: The Betty Broderick Story will give true crime fans a lot to think about

Posted by for People

Warning: spoilers for Netflix’s Dirty John: The Betty Broderick Story ahead.

Updated on 14 August: The Betty Broderick Story (aka the second season of the Dirty John anthology series) is now available to stream on Netflix.

Better still? Reviews are extremely positive, with many praising the series for working on two levels: as a typically addictive true crime series, and as a rather disturbing look at gaslighting, coercive control, and how women’s rights were eroded in the past.

The first season of the Dirty John series, of course, focused on con man John Meehan and the last woman he abused and manipulated before his death in 2016 – a case made famous by the incredibly addictive Dirty John podcast. However, season two is different for two reasons.

Firstly, this season is less interested in labelling the ‘Dirty John’ of the case: instead, it’s far more interested in the ruthlessness of divorce. Secondly, viewers are far less likely to be aware of the real-life events which inspired The Betty Broderick Story. Indeed, many may not have heard of the eponymous Betty. At all. 

And so, with that in mind, we’re here to do our best to unravel the case for you all.

Who was the real Betty Broderick?

As reported on 11 August: Betty Bisceglia (portrayed in the series by Amanda Peet) was born in 1947 to devout Roman Catholic parents, who she later claimed trained her to become a housewife from a very young age.

That didn’t stop her excelling in her studies, though: in fact, Betty met her future husband Dan Broderick (played by Christian Slater) while she was attending the University of Notre Dame in 1965.

The couple married four years later, and Betty returned from her honeymoon pregnant with the first of her and Dan’s five children. And, despite her parents’ strict beliefs about a husband supporting his wife and children, Dan went back to law school and Betty became the main provider for the Broderick family, working hard to pay off their bills and keep food on the table.

It paid off: Dan was quickly hired by one of San Diego’s top law firms, and the family moved to an ‘American Dream’ house in the suburbs.

All seemed to be going incredibly well for the Broderick family. Until, of course, Dan’s affair with his legal assistant, Linda Kolkena (played by Rachel Heller), came to light.

Broderick vs Broderick

Divorce is the closest most people will come to war in their lives,” Peet’s character says in the trailer (via a voiceover).

“And that is what war is: who controls who. If you don’t control them, they control you.”

The Betty Broderick Story on Netflix
The Betty Broderick Story is streaming on Netflix now.

Described by Oprah Winfrey as one of “America’s messiest divorces” – even before it ended in double homicide – Dan and Betty’s acrimonious, five-year-long divorce process made national news.

And, as The Betty Broderick Story showrunner Alexandra Cunningham tells Variety, the enormous impact of these divorce proceedings on Betty’s emotional state is felt throughout the series.

“A lot of our research [showed] women specifically fought so hard for ‘no fault’ divorce where they would not have to go into court and play the victim and prove how terrible their husband was just to get money that they were entitled to,” explains Cunningham.

“But that actually has resulted in a lot of unfair treatment of women in a courtroom because there’s no assumption that they need to be taken care of, and I think a lot of people don’t know that. They think that in community property states, it’s just 50/50. Those issues alone, for me, would make it worth doing the show.”

At the time of the couple’s divorce, Dan was a very prominent local lawyer, serving as the president of the San Diego Bar Association, which made it extremely difficult for Betty to find a lawyer willing to represent her in the divorce. And she also believed that Dan used his legal influence to sell their house against her wishes and win sole custody of their children – although it’s worth noting that it was Betty who left her children on his doorstep.]

“The children were just a ball being passed back and forth, which was completely inappropriate,” says Cunningham. “That’s how low she sank.”

The fallout 

After the divorce was finalised, Dan married Linda. Betty’s behaviour, though, became frighteningly unpredictable.

She left hundreds of obscene messages on Dan and Linda’s answering machine. She ignored numerous restraining orders. She vandalised their home. And she even drove her car into the front door despite the fact that their children were inside the house at the time. 

Netflix’s The Betty Broderick Story: Amanda Peet as Betty Broderick.
Netflix’s The Betty Broderick Story: Amanda Peet as Betty Broderick.

The murder

On 5 November 1989, Betty broke into Dan and Linda’s house, slipped into their bedroom, and fatally shot them both as they slept. Forensic evidence suggests that Dan did not die immediately, and that Betty removed a phone from his reach to ensure he could not call for help.

She was convicted in 1991, receiving a sentence of 32 years-to-life in prison. And, now 72 years old, she is currently still serving that sentence.

How Netflix’s The Betty Broderick Story presents the case

“Betty, I would argue, is a victim in her own mind,” Cunningham says. 

“I cannot justify what she ultimately did, but I wanted to tell a story about why she got to that point… [because] she’s not the first or last person to shoot people dead in this country because of perception of what has happened to their self-identity and their lives.”

The showrunner adds: “I wanted to re-examine the whole, ‘Here’s a crazy, evil woman who did this purely out of jealousy’, and then to [have viewers put themselves] in her place in the narrative she constructed herself.”

Netflix’s Dirty John: The Betty Broderick Story premieres on Friday 14 August.

Sign up for the latest news and must-read features from Stylist, so you don't miss out on the conversation.

By entering my email I agree to Stylist’s Privacy Policy

Images: Isabella Vosmikova/USA Network/NBCU Photo Bank via Getty Images.

Share this article

Kayleigh Dray

Kayleigh Dray is Stylist’s digital editor-at-large. Her specialist topics include comic books, films, TV and feminism. On a weekend, you can usually find her drinking copious amounts of tea and playing boardgames with her friends.

Recommended by Kayleigh Dray