People

“Paddington 2 is the best-reviewed film of all time – so why was it snubbed at the Oscars?”

Posted by
Kayleigh Dray
Published

It’s official: Paddington 2 – a film about a friendly, polite and thoughtful CGI bear – is now the best-reviewed film of all time. And yet, despite this, everyone’s favourite bear from Peru was downright ignored by the Academy. Why?

Last year was, undeniably, a bleak one. President Trump was busily bragging about the size of his nuclear button, while the Justice Secretary confirmed there would be no judicial review into the decision to release rapist John Worboys. Elsewhere, Emmanuel Macron warned Brits that we’re burning our bridges with Europe (yes, Brexit – again), a critically-acclaimed actress was paid less than 1% of her male co-star’s salary, and new data revealed that man-made global warming had overtaken the influence of natural trends on climate.

And yet, in spite of all this, there was an overriding message of hope for the future: the ongoing #MeToo movement, for example, allowed us to speak openly about sexual expectations and consent, while the Time’s Up initiative vowed to help less privileged women protect themselves from sexual misconduct and the fallout that inevitably comes from reporting it. Theresa May promoted 11 women and doubled the number of ethnic minorities in her government, in a bid to ensure it “looks more like the country it serves”. Stylist raised the profiles of brilliant women past and present – and empowered future generations to follow their lead – with our Visible Women campaign. L’Oreal teamed up with Muslim beauty influencer Amena Khan to encourage conversations around personal identity and societal expectations when it comes to beauty. The British government appointed its first ever minister for loneliness.

The list goes on and on: no matter how many ways you look at 2018, it was a year which saw people doing their best to promote love, kindness and inclusivity. So it came as little surprise to learn that it was also the year in which Paddington 2 – a film which is based almost entirely on those core principles – became the best-reviewed film of all time.

And I, for one, couldn’t have been happier to hear it.

I went to see Paddington 2 with one of my closest friends on a cold and overwhelmingly soggy day, somewhere in the dead space between Christmas and New Year.

Admittedly, this was not our first choice of activity: we had originally planned to go for a wintry walk through Epping Forest and meander our way to a cosy pub nearby. As such, I’d gone to bed dreaming of muddy wellies and foaming pints of craft beer – but, when I woke up to icy rain and an iron-grey sky, I was forced to admit that we needed to change our plans for something more… well, more indoorsy.

After an incredibly long WhatsApp conversation (you know the kind: two very polite people just keep saying ‘I don’t mind what we do, really, whatever you want’ until the end of time), we somehow got to talking about a certain CGI bear – and all the rave reviews he’d been getting from cinemagoers.

“My brother went to see it,” my friend solemnly informed me, “and he cried for two hours straight”.

Immediately, I was intrigued. Before either of us really knew what was happening, we were settling into the comfy sofa seats of a near-empty London cinema and giggling to ourselves about how silly we were being. But then the film started – and we didn’t speak, didn’t rustle our popcorn, didn’t even so much as glance at one another until long after the credits rolled. By which point, I hasten to add, we were sobbing so hard we could barely see anyway.

If you read the official synopsis, Paddington 2 doesn’t sound like much. The titular bear (so sweetly voiced by Ben Whishaw) “now happily settled with the Brown family and a popular member of the local community, picks up a series of odd jobs to buy the perfect present for his Aunt Lucy’s 100th birthday, only for the gift to be stolen”.

So far, so basic – so what gives? Why are critics and audience members (myself included) so in love with this film?

Let’s break it down…

It’s ridiculously beautiful

Paddington 2 channels the precise symmetry, eye-catching backdrops, and obscure colour palettes of Wes Anderson – but somehow manages to push that stylisation to dazzling new levels of aesthetic delirium. Everything is picturesque, everything is incredibly dream-like, and everything feels as far removed from the real world as possible, despite being set in overwhelmingly familiar locations.

It boasts a truly brilliant cast

The main cast are all back and, if possible, better than ever. Whishaw’s Paddington is impossibly charming, Hugh Bonneville’s pleasantly exasperated Mr. Brown is having a very familiar midlife crisis, Sally Hawkins’s warm Mrs. Brown is the eccentric heroine we’ve long been craving and Peter Capaldi’s xenophobic Mr Curry is every bit as likely to raise your hackles as ever. This time, though, we have a new villain in the form of Hugh Grant’s egomaniacal Phoenix Buchanan – a hammy local actor who is every bit as hilarious as he is diabolical. Win, win.

It’s the perfect love letter to London

One day Paddington, while visiting a gift shop in search of a present for his beloved aunt, stumbles upon a book filled with gorgeous pop-up illustrations of London landmarks. In a gloriously animated sequence, Paddington finds himself happily lost amid the book’s three-dimensional pages, and we see that it’s the perfect gift for someone who always wanted to visit the city but never got the chance - just like his Aunt Lucy (Imelda Staunton). Perhaps more importantly, though, it forces us to take a long, hard look at our capital through the eyes of an outsider – and reminds us to appreciate it fully.

It reminds us what the word ‘family’ truly means

A flashback at the beginning of the film sees a young Aunt Lucy risking her life to save a tiny, orphaned cub from a raging river, before welcoming the little bear (yes, it’s Paddington) into her home. For years, she raises him on a diet of adventure and marmalade sandwiches – and, no matter how far apart they may be (she lives in the Home for Retired Bears in deepest, darkest Peru, he with the Browns in their Windsor Gardens house), their love for one another never fades. Hers is the voice Paddington hears in his head when times are rough, hers is the birthday that encourages him to work day and night to afford a present, and hers is the face he most wishes to see when he is at his lowest.

Of course, Aunt Lucy isn’t the only member of Paddington’s chosen family: the love and support he receives from the Browns is both encouraging and endearing – and, beyond his household, Paddington is also a buoyant and helpful presence connected to the caring residents of his community. So, when the chips are down, it makes sense that every last one of them drops what they’re doing to help their furry friend.

All in all, it’s a firm reminder that the word ‘family’ doesn’t have anything to do with genes or legalities: instead, it refers to people in your life who want you in theirs. The ones who accept you for who you truly are. The ones who would do anything to see you smile – and, most importantly of all, those who love you, no matter what.

It’s genuinely a gripping story

Paddington gets wrongfully accused of theft and winds up in a dank Victorian prison, filled with cutthroats, thugs and bullies! The Browns are forced to embark on a Da Vinci Code-esque treasure hunt all over London in a bid to clear his name! A mysterious nun wreaks havoc in St Paul’s Cathedral! Hidden treasure! High-speed car, train and aircraft chases! MORE!

Honestly, it’s exciting. The kind of exciting that squeezes all the breath out of you because it’s so… well, because it’s so blooming unexpected. Thought you were getting a sedate story about a bear in a floppy hat? Think again, kiddo.

It challenges us to be kind

It’s all too easy, in these troubled times, to shut yourself off from the world. To turn off the news when those ‘bad’ stories come on. To ignore the homeless person sleeping outside your local tube station. To assume the worst of everyone, every single time.

Paddington, though, is relentless in his positivity: he may be incarcerated with vagabonds of the worst kind, but his commitment to decency, thoughtfulness and impeccable manners soon melts even those hardest of hearts. As Aunt Lucy always says: “If we’re kind and polite, the world will be right”.

In contrast, we have the vile Mr Curry, who has always hated Paddington with every fibre of his being. Why? Because Paddington is, in his eyes, an undesirable outsider – and a damaging influence on the local community.

“We don’t want him here,” he screams into a megaphone, seemingly speaking for everyone in the tight-knit London community.

Mr. Brown, though, soon informs him that this absolutely is not the case.

“Of course you don’t,” he snaps. “You never have! As soon as you set eyes on that bear you made up your mind about him. Well Paddington’s not like that. He looks for the good in all of us and somehow, he finds it! It’s why he makes friends wherever he goes. And it’s why Windsor Gardens is a happier place whenever he’s around.”

It’s a highly resonant (albeit not-so-subtle) reminder that, at its heart, Paddington Bear is a story about a refugee trying to make a home for himself in a strange country – and how vital his contribution to society can be, if only everyone could look past his immigrant status and make him feel welcome.

Essentially, though, this marmalade-encrusted figure shows us that, if we treat everyone with respect and compassion, the world is destined to be a better place.

It warms the cockles of your cold, cold heart

This film, with all of its lyrical sweetness, is the perfect antidote to the nightmarish reality we’re currently living in. If you don’t shed a single tear – and your heart doesn’t swell two sizes bigger when you’re watching it – you probably aren’t a real human at all.

In an ideal world, yes, you should see it with a beloved member of your own chosen ‘family’ – but you could just as easily go with that one person you secretly suspect might be a robot. Just to… well, just to check that isn’t actually the case.

With all this in mind, is it any wonder that so many people have expressed outrage over the fact that Paddington 2 has been snubbed in EVERY SINGLE CATEGORY of the 2019 Academy Awards? Exactly. 

Check it out:

So who did make the cut for the Animated Feature Film category at the Oscars 2019?

Think The Incredibles 2, Isle of Dogs, Mirai, Ralph Breaks The Internet, and Spider-Man: Into The Spider-Verse (the latter of which, we’ll admit, is bloody brilliant).

One final comment from an incensed Paddington 2 fan, though:

Well, quite. Fingers crossed that #JusticeforPaddington stars trending soon, eh?

Images: Warner Bros, iStock

Topics

Share this article

Author

Kayleigh Dray

Kayleigh Dray is editor of Stylist.co.uk, where she chases after rogue apostrophes and specialises in films, comic books, feminism and television. On a weekend, you can usually find her drinking copious amounts of tea and playing boardgames with her friends. 

Recommended by Kayleigh Dray

People

All the women up for awards at the 2019 Oscars

From the biggest screen stars to the women making magic behind the scenes.

Posted by
Moya Crockett
Published
Books

As his creator Michael Bond dies, the best quotes from Paddington Bear

“I’ll never be like other people, but that’s alright, because I’m a bear”

Posted by
Anna Brech
Published
People

Colette is a pacey period drama with thoroughly modern themes

Keira Knightley is back at her very best in this brilliant biopic

Posted by
Emily Gargan
Published
Life

The Favourite is unlike any period drama you’ve ever seen before

“Mirror, mirror on the wall, who is the Queen bitch of them all?”

Posted by
Mayran Yusuf
Published
Life

How Mary Poppins Returns completely rewrites Disney’s classic “happy ever after”

Think Emily Blunt’s new movie is just a whimsical story about a flying nanny? Think again: it’s much more revolutionary than that.

Posted by
Kayleigh Dray
Published